'mM
HKiiiipp
BRARY OF CONGRESS
DODO'=3bD3
Class
Bcok__l_i
COFmiGHT DEPOSm
^^^H ^ MttKKwM^m^Bs j£la ^^^Hl
^^^^^^^ft^ x]fliC!'jVf[i ^H^L ^^H
^^^^HM^ 1 fl
^^^iHiyiBf^fj^
i i
a
C/i
The Tragedy of Bitlis
By
GRACE H. KNAPP
Being Mainly the Narratives of
GRisELL M. McLaren
AND
MYRTLE O. SHANE
ILLUSTRATED
New York Chicago
Fleming H. Revell Company
London and Edinburgh
Copyright, 1919, by
FLEMING H. REVELL COMPANY /
<\,(,
f
1^
m 29 ifift
New York: 158 Fifth Avenue
Chicago: 17 North Wabash Ave.
London: 21 Paternoster Square
Edinburgh: 75 Princes Street
©CU535r)18
To the memory of those dear to me.
Father, Mother, Brother, **Aunt Charlotte and
Aunt Mary " Ely, who, in the name of Christ,
spent their lives for the Armenians of Bitlis,
this story of the sufferings ayid heroism of the
people whom they loved and worked for is
affectionately dedicated
Preface
AFTER their return to this country in
October, 1917, Miss McLaren and Miss
Shane each wrote an account of what
occurred in BitUs during the summer and early-
autumn of 1915. A harmony of the two nar-
ratives constitutes two-thirds of the present vol-
ume, entire paragraphs or pages being quoted
word for word where this was feasible. Every
incident is absolutely authentic, for the two
American ladies have related without exaggera-
tion what they have seen with their own eyes
or experienced in their own persons.
I happened to be in Van when the war began
and shared the fortunes of the Americans and
Armenians there during the events briefly
sketched in the chapter entitled " The Besieged
City." But Bitlis was my birthplace and child-
hood's home, and I had taught there for nine
years. So the scenes I have described are dear
and famihar scenes and the " Ely residence,"
5
6 PEEFACE
now looted, deserted and bare, my old home,
once filled with relics of my parents' long life
within its walls and endeared by a thousand ties
of association. Pastor Khachig, Deegeen Lu-
centag, Deegeen Heghene, and Kevork Effendi
were old and valued friends, together with many
others whose names are not mentioned in these
pages, and Miss Shane's pupils had once been
mine. One of them a few weeks ago related to
me the sequel of Miss McLaren's and Miss
Shane's narrative and the story of her own
strange romance.
The last chapter also describes the present
condition in the Russian Caucasus of the refu-
gees from the Van and Bitlis provinces and the
wonderful work of relief and rehabilitation un-
dertaken by the American Committee for Ar-
menian and Syrian Relief.
Grace H. Knapp.
Contents
I.
BiTLIS
9
II.
The Besieged City . . . .
15
III.
An American Woman in a Turkish
Hospital
21
IV.
During the Siege . . . .
29
V.
Across the Lake to Bitlis
35
VI.
Twelve Thousand Refugees in
Bitlis
44
VII.
Massacre of the Men
49
VIII.
Deportation of the Women .
59
IX.
The Russian Army Approaches
69
X.
The Passing of Miss Charlotte Ely
74
XI.
After the Russian Retreat .
82
XII.
Sister Martha . . . .
93
XIII.
The Pioneer Parents of George
Perkins Knapp . . . .
96
XIV.
Greater Love Hath No Man .
112
XV.
Miss McLaren Falls III ; German
Officers Visit Bitlis .
127
XVI.
MusTiFA Bey and the Schoolgirls
133
XVII.
Miss McLaren and Miss Shane
Obliged to Leave Bitlis
140
XVIII.
Sequels
144
Illustrations
Sister Cities With Interwoven Destinies
A nook in Bitlis
Van — from the citadel
Charlotte E. Ely , , •
Mary A. C. Ely . . • ,
Alzina Churchill Knapp
George Perkins Knapp .
Home Life in an Armenian Village
Life in an ArxMEnian Refugee Camp — Port Said
Industrial Relief of the American Committee for
Relief in the Near East ....
Shoe-making
Lace-work
Frontispiece
FACING page
74
74
74
74
I02
I02
148
1
BITLIS
SPRING in a little Armenian town in the
heart of Kurdistan : hills, bleakly bare
and brown the rest of the year, were
faintly green with a sparse evanescent herbage ;
poplars lining streets and waterways were spires
of pale green smoke bursting into beryl flame
where the sun shot through; fruit trees behind
high garden walls were masses of white bloom.
Everywhere there was the sound and scent of
running water, for the city was a city of streams
and waterfalls and fountains, a city high, high
up among the mountains, so enfolded within its
hills, so swallowed up in deep narrow ravines
that the whole of it could not be seen at once
from the top of any of the surrounding peaks.
The most densely built part was like an
amphitheater, flat-roofed stone houses climbing
tier above tier half-way up one face of Water
Tower Hill, a hill as triangular and steep as a
pyramid and crowned by an old tower whose
surmised purpose had given it its name.
9
10 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
In the center of the amphitheater was an
enormous ancient fortress, picturesque with
towers and battlements, rising cHff-like above a
hive of low-roofed bazaars. Around its base
and under half a score of arched stone bridges,
rushed a mountain torrent that had entered the
city by one narrow gorge and left it by another,
the western side of which was covered with the
orchards and gardens of squatter Kurds. A
smaller stream leaped down a crevice in the hills
to meet it here, turning perforce on its way
primitive grindstones in a mill that looked like
a feudal baron's stronghold atop its pinnacle of
peninsulated rock.
The eastern side was a high bluff into the face
of which was cut a highway leading from the
center of the city to the south. The top of the
bluff was a small plateau; near its northern edge
the buildings of the American Mission looked
down sheer two hundred feet into the well of
the amphitheater with its mosques and mina-
rets, fortress and bazaars.
The Merchant in Persia, visiting Bitlis early
in the sixteenth century, found this fortress or
castle occupied by a Kurdish prince owning only
nominal allegiance to the Shah of Persia.
BITLIS 11
Tavernier a century later was impressed by
the power of the Bey of Bitlis, " who acknowl-
edged neither the Shah of Persia nor the Sultan
of Turkey and was courted by both on account
of the strategical value of his city barring the
communications between Aleppo and Tabriz,
He also resided in the castle approached by
three successive drawbridges and could place
in the field 20,000 to 25,000 horsemen besides a
quantity of good infantry. In the eighteenth
century the Padre Maurizio Garzoni speaks of
the dynasty of Bitlis as one of the five consider-
able principalities which divided between them
the Kurdistan of his day. The last of this old
order of princes at Bitlis was a man of many-
sided and remarkable character, whose romantic
history one peruses with breathless excitement
in the dry reports and correspondence of Consul
Brant, the eye and ear of the famous Stratford
Canning. After a life of chequered fortune and
fox-like resistance to the Turkish power he was
finally overwhelmed by the operations of Reshid
Pasha and taken a prisoner to Constantinople
in 1849/' '
This prince, Sherif Bey, built a fortified castle
*H. F. B. I,ynch, "Armenia," Vol. II, Chap. VI.
12 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
long ago razed to the ground, on an emi-
nence, still bearing his name, which links the
small plateau to Water Tower Hill.
Once since the rule of Turkish pashas began
have the Kurds of the region attempted to re-
gain their old power. In the spring of 1914 they
marched into the city, a harlequin mob in their
gay native costumes, and armed chiefly with
short swords, scimitars and knives. Chanting
weirdly, they took up a position on Sherif Bey's
Hill in full view of the government buildings
and within direct range of fire from the bar-
racks. They did not fear the enemy's bullets,
for these would be warded ofif by the magic
power of their religious leaders, the sheikhs.
The machine guns startled them and they
scurried to cover in an old Armenian church,
from which for a while they returned the fire
with a few old muskets. But when cannon-balls
began to demolish the walls of their shelter and
it was discovered that the invulnerable sheikhs
had deserted them and were in hiding they fled
in utter rout.
More than a year had passed since then and
Turkey had for months been at war with Russia,
but the little town was quiet and peaceful this
BITLIS 13
bright May morning. Why not? It had known
such terrible massacres during the past quarter
century that a war with a foe from without, a
war in which the Armenians themselves were
fighting and proving their bravery and loyalty,
seemed by comparison a thing not to be so
greatly feared. And the governor of the prov-
ince had thus far proved himself able to keep in
order the turbulent elements within his vilayet.
So there seemed no good reason why three of
the small circle of American missionaries should
not now take their furloughs which were due
and for which a more convenient season might
never occur. Mr. and Mrs. H. A. Maynard had
worked for seven years in Bitlis, seven strenu-
ous years filled with difficult problems, anxie-
ties, sorrows, which only calm good judgment,
devotedness and courage such as theirs could
face and endure; they greatly needed now a
year at home. With them was leaving Miss
Mary D. Uline, who had begun her missionary
life in Erzerum but who had taught for four
years in the Mt. Holyoke Seminary of Bitlis and
had been its principal for two years.
It was the Armenian Ascension Day, and the
streets were filled with people in gala attire.
14 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
Hundreds of Armenian friends " set the travel-
lers on the road," according to their custom.
After these turned back, Miss Ely, Miss Shane,
Mr. Knapp and the Armenian pastor and head
teacher of the boys' school prepared a farewell
picnic lunch in a shaded spot by the side of the
road within sight and sound of the river. With
hopeful prophecies concerning the future, with
laughter and with jest, the members of the little
group tried to hide from each other the doubts,
misgivings and sense of loss with which the
approaching separation filled their hearts.
Yet they did not dream that at this very mo-
ment their American friends of the nearest sis-
ter mission, ninety miles away across Lake Van,
were in a besieged city, cut off utterly from
communication with the outside world; a be-
sieged city that had held out gallantly against
desperate odds for nearly four weeks but had
now lost all hope and was fighting grimly but
to put off a little longer the inevitable end.
II
THE BESIEGED CITY
DJEVDET BEY, the Governor-General
of Van, brother-in-law of Enver Pasha,
Minister of War, had planned for April
19, 1915, a general massacre of his Armenian
subjects. On that day soldiers and Kurds, in
some instances taking cannon with them, at-
tacked the smaller towns and the villages of the
province, and met with little or no resistance
because most of the able-bodied men had been
drafted into the Sultan's army and those who
were left had very little ammunition. Fifty-five
thousand men, women and children were
slaughtered; thousands, wounded, managed to
escape and flee to the capital, while their homes
were looted and burned behind them.
In the city of Van itself Djevdet Bey's plans
met with an unexpected check. He had endeav-
oured by exorbitant demands and by acts of
treachery to incite the Armenians to " rebel-
's
16 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
lion " which would justify putting them to
death. But the Armenians were exceedingly
careful not to precipitate trouble by any overt
act of their own, which, they very well knew,
would be made an excuse for massacres all over
the Empire. At the same time they determined
to put up a light in case of attack, and they dis-
covered that lines of entrenchment were being
secretly drawn around the Armenian quarter.
This Armenian quarter was about a mile
square and was separated by a Turkish quarter
from the business section in the old walled city
two miles distant. In the walled city was the
famous Castle Rock, a citadel that could pro-
tect— or threaten — the bazaars and dwellings
huddled around its base.
Most of the Armenian men had enlisted or
had been drafted into the army. Between
twelve and fifteen hundred young men were left,
trained riflemen, though they possessed but
three hundred rifles among them. They manned
and barricaded, secretly, positions all around the
Armenian quarter, then — waited. " If the Ar-
menians fire one shot," Djevdet Bey had told
the Americans, " I will destroy the city utterly,
leaving not one child as high as my knee."
THE BESIEGED CITY 17
The Armenians did not fire that first shot.
Turkish soldiers fired it, and within an hour the
Armenian quarter, with its thirty thousand in-
habitants, was in a state of siege.
At the same time the Armenians in the walled
city were put on the defensive. Cannon on Cas-
tle Rock were fired down upon their sun-dried
brick houses, wrecking the upper stories. Al-
though there were only thirty fighting men here
they held out bravely to the very end.
The story of the siege of Van, together with
the events that preceded and followed, is fully
told in Dr. C. D. Ussher's " An American Physi-
cian in Turkey." ' It is very briefly related here
on account of Miss Grisell McLaren's connec-
tion with the tragedy of Van and the tragedy of
Bitlis.
When Turkey entered the war in the autumn
of 1914, a military hospital was opened on the
outskirts of the city about a mile from the
American premises. The Governor asked the
missionaries to send one of their number to help
in this hospital, and Miss McLaren was chosen.
Not far from the American premises was an
"Ambassador Morgenthau also devotes considerable
space to it in his book.
18 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
Armenian orphanage under the management of
a Swiss gentleman, Herr Sporri, his wife and
daughter, and three German ladies. Hundreds
of the orphans of the 1895-96 massacres had
been taken care of for some years by the Ameri-
can missionaries. Later these Germans had
come in, and it had been thought best in order
not to duplicate and waste effort to turn over all
of the remaining orphans to their care. Frau-
lein Kleiss (Schwester Marthe, or Sister Martha
as we called her), was also asked to help and
consented to do so. The two ladies worked
during the day at the hospital, returning at
night. Some of their pre-siege experiences are
related by Miss McLaren in the following
chapter.
Although the Americans did not know that
Djevdet Bey was planning a massacre, it was
quite evident on April lYth that there was going
to be serious trouble of some sort, so when he
asked Sister Martha and Miss McLaren to stay
at the hospital night and day for ten days, they
understood there was to be no going and com-
ing and they must either accede to his request
or stay at home for that length of time. The
Armenian workers begged them not to leave*
THE BESIEGED CITY 19
their presence might save these men from death.
The thought of the way in which the poor pa-
tients would be neglected during their absence
also strongly influenced them and they decided
to remain at their post. But throughout the
siege they held no communication with their as-
sociates nor did the Vali vouchsafe any informa-
tion to the Americans concerning Miss McLar-
en's well-being, although during the early part
of the siege there was occasional communication
between him and their official representative,
the Italian consular agent.
Djevdet Bey, indeed, in spite of the fact that
hitherto he had had most friendly relations with
the missionaries, in spite of the fact that scores
of Turkish soldiers had been cared for in their
Red Cross hospital and that he was assured they
were maintaining an attitude of strict neutral-
ity— which as Americans they were bound to do
— was enraged by their humanitarian efforts in
behalf of the non-combatants. They housed six
thousand refugees on their own premises, or-
ganized a city government and a system of food
distribution, and cared for the sick and wounded.
Epidemics raged, for over ten thousand villagers
escaped to the city, provisions ran very low, and
20 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
crowding, exposure and privation brought the
usual consequences in their train. Djevdet Bey-
threatened to bombard the American premises
and he fulfilled his threat on the twenty-fourth
and twenty-fifth days of the siege. Shells
entered every building in the compound.
This proved to be a burst of foiled spite, how-
ever, for in the afternoon and evening of the
15th of May the Turkish troops were with-
drawn from the city and it was soon discovered
that practically its entire Turkish population
had already fled in boats across the lake to
Bitlis.
The Americans hastened the next morning to
the military hospital only to find that Miss
McLaren and Sister Martha had been sent with
their patients to Bitlis four days earlier.
On the 18th the Russians, whose approach
had put to flight the Turks, entered the city.
Ill
AN AMERICAN WOMAN IN A TURKISH
HOSPITAL
{Miss McLaren^ s Story)
**^TI ^HE Van hospital was used to serve the
I portion of the Ottoman army that
was fighting against the Russians be-
tween Van and the Persian border. Of those
who reached the hospital many were wounded,
many had feet or hands frozen by lying day and
night in the snow and many others were ill from
exposure and improper food and shelter. There
was no well-organized Red Cross or Red Cres-
cent ambulance service — in fact, there were
scarcely any roads over which four-wheeled
vehicles could have travelled even if there had
been any such vehicles available. The patients
were cared for first in the field hospitals, which
were usually in dark, dirty stables, and from
these a few at a time were sent to the central
hospital at Van. They had to come on the
backs of donkeys, horses, or even oxen. Any
who were unable to sit up and hold on were
21
22 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
bound, face down, on the back of the animal.
Often when they arrived some poor fellows
would be hanging over the side head down,
sometimes with their heads between the ani-
mal's front feet. No nurses were ever sent with
such a caravan, and the muleteers did not care
what happened. Such a journey required from
four to ten days, and stops were made each
night in a village, where the men had to lie with-
out beds on some earthen floor. Lucky they
were if they had a roof over their heads.
" Where the roads were good ox-carts were
used, but only for the worst cases, and the poor
men had to lie for days on these, clad only in
miserable rags, sometimes with a little hay
under them and an overcoat for covering, some-
times with nothing as protection, either below
or above. On arrival the dead had to be re-
moved first before the living could be gotten at,
and more of these ox-cart passengers w^ere sent
to the morgue than to the hospital. Few of
those who were living when they arrived re-
covered.
" At first we wondered why we received so
few heavily wounded men, but our wondering
soon ceased when we heard the patients tell of
IN A TUEKISH HOSPITAL 23
how their companions were left dead or dying
by the roadside. Enver Pasha is credited with
having said that Turkish soldiers had no identi-
fication cards or discs at the beginning of the
war because the dead Turk is of no use to the
Turkish Government. The severely wounded
soldier was often left to die uncared for on the
battle-field or by the roadside, probably because
he could be of no further use to the government
and surgical supplies were too precious to waste
on such.
" During the early weeks of the war our pa-
tients were anxious to be made * tabourdji '
(discharged and returned to the front). They
were all eagerness to fight to help their allies,
the Germans. One young officer said, * No mat-
ter what we sacrifice, it will still be little when
we think of what we owe to Germany.' A few
weeks later a companion, who had heard this
remark, was in the operating room watching as
the surgeon amputated the foot of a poor fellow
who had already lost one leg and would lose a
hand also. He said, 'May the curse of God
rest upon the man who began this war, whether
he is in London or Berlin or wherever he is.*
We soon found that men were removing their
24 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
bandages, and doing things to get their wounds
infected and thus delay their departure from
the hospital. The spirit of loyalty to their allies
had changed, except in a few cases, to bitter
hate, and more than one German officer has said
to me, ' If the war goes against Germany the
Turks will rise up and kill every German in the
Turkish Empire.'
" The hospital was a large, new building, with
comfortable accommodations for 200 patients.
The beds were of iron, each provided with one
mattress of straw and one of cotton, which soon
grew lumpy and hard as brick. Sheets were too
narrow and short to protect the mattresses; pil-
lows were used for months at a time without
cleansing; there was not enough clothing to
keep the patients clean and no bathing facilities
— men were put to bed in the condition in which
they came off the road; they were covered with
vermin and the work in the laundry was so
poorly done it was not safe to handle the gar-
ments that had been washed.
" Sister Martha and I made up our minds
that there must be some radical changes in the
management of affairs or we could not work.
A hospital committee was formed of prominent
IN A TUEKISH HOSPITAL 25
Turks and foreigners. For a few days members
of this committee haunted the place, holding
conferences with the staff, finding out what was
needed and promising to have everything com-
plete in a very short time. Two members were
to spend several hours each day going about the
wards, watching the dressing of wounds and
attending operations. They began bravely, but
it was really funny to see how quickly they
sought the open air after a visit to a ward.
They * did not like the smell,' they said, and
left. The life of this committee of high ideals
was painfully short, but before it went out we
were given an adequate supply of the most nec-
essary things, and a small room was fitted up
for bathing, each patient being allowed one pail
of water and one small piece of poor soap.
" The officials were very free with their hands
or whips, maintaining that a common soldier
would do his duty only through fear of physical
suffering. Patients, too, who writhed when the
doctor cruelly probed a wound or used a knife
freely, were often struck to make them keep
still. We put a stop to the beating of servants,
and after one patient died, from shock appar-
ently, after undergoing a very painful operation
26 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
without anesthetic, dressings and operations
were more humanely done.
" Sister Martha was a splendidly trained
nurse, with several years of experience in Ger-
man hospitals and clinics. She had all the quali-
ties of a German general and ordered everybody
about from the head doctor to the humblest
nurse. Inferiors almost worshipped her, and to
them her word was law, but men who, because
of their military rank, should have been manag-
ing affairs, resented being ordered about by a
woman. Jokingly they called her * Bin bashi
(Major) Martha.' However, they realized that
the things she demanded were reasonable and
necessary for the good of the work.
" In spite of seemingly insurmountable difH-
culties, in a short time there was a marked
change in the comfort and efBciency of the hos-
pital. The patients could not find words to ex-
press their gratitude, and it was not uncommon
to hear an old patient telling a new one in re-
gard to one or the other of us that there was
* no better doctor in the whole country than
she.' I knew little about nursing, but I kept
the nurses, and even the doctors sometimes, at-
tending to business, and I administered to the
m A TUEKISH HOSPITAL 27
poor men generous doses of cheer and encour-
agement which I am sure often did them more
good than the stuff the doctors prescribed with-
out knowing what was the matter with them.
The medicines ordered were given or not, ac-
cording to the temper of the head druggist, who
altered prescriptions to suit himself. Some days
no medicines were given at all because there
was no one in the drug room who had skill or
inclination to prepare them.
** One of the duties I enjoyed most was choos-
ing patients to be sent to the American hospital.
Dr. Ussher had Red Cross funds for caring for
a certain number of soldiers in his hospital and
I had to see that the number wafe kept filled up.
Sister Martha and I usually chose the ones who,
we thought, had little chance of recovery if they
remained where they were. The doctors were
always glad to get rid of troublesome cases.
" Every evening I went to see how the men
liked their new quarters. After a real bath,
clean bed, clean clothes, they looked like differ-
ent beings. As soon as I appeared all would
begin to talk at once. * We never knew there
was such a place as this on earth. This is
heaven. Just look at us, we are clean and we
28 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
have had enough to eat to-day. They give us
all we want, and it is so good ! God grant you
life for your kindness to us ! '
" We had been told at the beginning that we
must make no attempt to change the religion of
the Moslem patients, but for a long time we
were allowed to give out portions of Scripture
to them to read. These were very eagerly
sought for, and the few who could read were
kept busy reading aloud to the others. The
doctor who had permitted this left for the front
after a time and the next morning the superin-
tendent of the hospital collected all the books
and tracts and would not allow us to give others.
The men often asked us what salary we were
receiving from the government for our services,
and they could not comprehend why we should
be working for nothing for the Turkish Gov-
ernment. This gave us the opportunity we
sought of telling them of the love of Christ, and
that we were serving them because of that
love."
IV
DURING THE SIEGE
"^"^ THEN, in compliance with Djevdet
^y^ Bey's request, we decided, April
I7th, to stay both night and day
at the hospital for a time, we were given very
comfortable quarters, a large, sunny room
in a house next the hospital. The superintend-
ent was obliged to furnish rugs from his own
home and I believe some of the furniture was
his. A soldier was assigned to wait on us, which
he did very nicely, when he was not away bury-
ing his father-in-law or attending to some other
business. Of food we did not have a great vari-
ety— meat, milk and cooking butter in abun-
dance, and occasionally other things. We had
to eat the hospital bread, there was no other —
dark, half-baked stuff full of straw and grit. Our
enjoyment of it did not increase when we saw it
thrown upon the ground in dirty sacks from the
same wagon in which the bodies of the dead
29
30 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
soldiers were taken to the graveyard. We fried
it and ate it and tried to forget. We knew that
Djevdet Bey was anxious to have us made as
comfortable as possible, but we did not know
until it was too late that he occasionally sent us
dainties for our table. The chief doctor ate
them and told us afterwards what a good dinner
he had had.
" The siege of Van began on the 20th of
April, 1915, early in the morning. We could
hear the cracking of the rifles, seemingly from
every direction, and the booming of the cannon
as they fired from the old city ' Castle ' down
onto the houses in the walled city in a vain
effort to destroy them. The singing of the bul-
lets at night as they came near our quarters
forced us to abandon our beds near the win-
dows and sleep on the floor. During the first
day or two we found it hard to work or to rest.
We pictured our Armenian friends as being
driven from their homes and cruelly murdered
without being able to defend themselves. Then
an Armenian doctor, who was being held at the
hospital as a prisoner, told us how the Arme-
nians had prepared themselves for what they
knew must come before long. Later the
DURING THE SIEGE 31
wounded Turkish soldiers who were brought to
the hospital often said, ' This is no way to fight.
We can do nothing against these Armenians.
They fight from behind the walls of their houses
where we cannot see them and we don't know
where to shoot. We are in plain sight in the
streets and they shoot us down.' Upon that we
felt better.
" During the siege we received a call or two
from a man calling himself a German officer.
As I remember him, he wore the uniform of a
Turkish captain. He told us that he was a na-
tive of Venezuela, had been in Alaska and had
been a cowboy on our own Western plains. He
had also been to school in Germany and claimed
to have a commission in the German army.
One day he sent a note to Sister Martha, who
immediately said, ' This settles it. He is not a
German officer, for no man who writes German
like this would ever receive a commission in our
army.'
" From his own story we knew that he di-
rected the bombardment of the walled city, but
he acknowledged that it had not been a very
successful piece of work.
" * The cannon-balls go through the thick
32 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
mud walls of the houses without destroying
them, and the Armenians are grateful to us for
having made another opening for them to shoot
us through/ His contempt for the Turks was
great, and we could not keep from laughing as
he told how the men went about carrying ex-
plosives in their arms and lighted cigarettes in
their mouths. Some of the awful wrecks of men
we saw who had been blown up by their own
cannon or ammunition proved that the common
soldiers did not fully understand the nature of
the materials with which they had to deal.
" Captain de Nogales, as he called himself,
was evidently a ' soldier of fortune,* adding to
his already varied experiences by helping the
Turks exterminate the Armenians. There was
a large mirror in the room. At the close of each
call the captain would bid us good-bye with a
handshake and a low bow, then straighten up,
click his heels in true German fashion, salute
his own reflection in the mirror, turn, bow to us
again and march out. His stay in Van was
short, and then he was off in search of new
adventures.
" The one spring-wagon was kept busy bring-
ing the wounded to the hospital and Sister
DTJEING THE SIEGE 33
Martha and I were often kept in the operating
room until nine or ten at night without any
supper, working with the Armenian surgeon on
the men who needed immediate operations.
The Turkish doctor, who was supposed to be at
the head of things, usually left before dark.
Sister Martha never thought about herself, but
always and only how she could relieve the suf-
ferings of others, and often she was so weak
that she could scarcely climb the stairs to our
room. Sometimes she was in such great pain
that she would sink to the floor unable to stand
up. No one besides myself knew of the trouble
that caused this suffering, and she never allowed
it to interfere with her work.
" The Turks were furious against the Arme-
nians, and always glad to find some new proof
of their * treachery.' The doctors said, * See
what kind of men your Armenians are * when
one or two were brought in wounded by dum-
dum, or by poisoned bullets. They stopped
talking when we told them that each one of the
men thus wounded had been shot by mistake by
Turkish soldiers.
" Djevdet Bey's * ten days ' passed, and still
another ten, and the end seemed no nearer than
34 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
at the first. Suddenly there began the hurried
transfer of patients across the lake to Bitlis,
We were told that this was only to make room
for other patients, but before many days they
said that the hospital was to be abandoned, and
asked Sister Martha and me if we would go to
Bitlis to help there. Before making our decision
we called on the Governor, who expressed deep
appreciation of all we had done and a desire that
we might see fit to continue our services in
Bitlis. However, he promised to do all in his
power to get us safely through to the Armenian
Hnes if we wished, where a white flag would in-
sure safe conduct to our homes. One of the of-
ficials suggested that we would be obliged to
sign a paper to the effect that we went at our
own desire, thus absolving the Turkish Govern-
ment from all responsibility in case anything
happened to us. The remark helped us to de-
cide that it was best to go with the patients.
On our return to the hospital this decision was
strengthened by the Armenian workers who
came and begged us again not to leave them or
they would all be killed.**
ACROSS THE LAKE TO BITLIS
" X SEEM to be unable to recall dates, but I
I know we left Van on a Thursday or Fri-
day night about the middle of May, 1915.
We had very little baggage — only one change
of clothing and a little bedding. Our food con-
sisted mostly of a lot of hospital bread fried.
We left the hospital in the ambulance and had
to go a roundabout way to get to the place
where the boats were waiting in order to avoid
passing too near the city gate, where the enemy
might be lying in wait. It was dark as Egypt
and we had to walk a long way through the
sand on the lake shore before we finally found
the boats. By the aid of a feeble lantern we
clambered up one gangplank across a sailboat
and down another narrow, springy board onto
the deck of the little gasoline launch that was
to carry us across the lake.
" Although we were told that they had been
35
36 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
waiting only for us, it was after two o'clock in
the morning before we were under way. What
caused the delay we never knew, but the cap-
tain had to go several times to consult with the
Governor, who lived some distance away.
*' Djevdet Bey had given written orders that
no one was to be carried on the motor-boat ex-
cept the two Schwesters and the two doctors,
but we found the cabin occupied by a Turkish
family who also had private permission from
the Governor to go with us and naturally they
intended to avail themselves of it. Sister
Martha and I were invited to share the cabin
with them, but as there seemed to be not even
standing room inside we declined as politely as
possible. But our bedding was on one of the
sailboats, it was bitterly cold and we did not
look forward with any enthusiasm to a night on
deck sailing across Lake Van. Finally the cap-
tain gave us his cabin. It was a tiny place with
wooden benches a foot wide on three sides and
not long enough to let one stretch out. How-
ever, we managed to get a little sleep, and at
daylight we were on deck again. The sea was
calm and beautiful and as a good breeze was
blowing, the eight large sailboats with us (fiv^
ACROSS THE LAKE TO BITLIS 37
filled with hospital patients and three with
Turkish families fleeing from the oncoming
Russians) went along at a good pace.
" Later our boat stopped at an island on
which there was a large Armenian monastery.
We climbed the hill eagerly with visions of a
good breakfast of eggs and milk and bread,
which the priests always willingly prepared for
travellers stopping there. We had difficulty in
gaining admission into the building, which was
a most unusual experience ; when we got in we
found two aged priests who seemed dazed and
either unable or unwilling to talk, and who re-
fused to give us anything to eat. At last we
gathered that the day before a lot of Turkish
soldiers had come to the island, killed one or
more of the priests and some of the orphan boys
and carried off all the sheep and chickens and
everything eatable in the place. In the church
we found everything overturned. Vestments
and other articles used in the church services
were scattered about on the floor, torn, broken
and destroyed. Silver crosses had been carried
away, every scrap of silver or gold had been
torn ofiF the mitres and other articles; not one
thing of value was to be found anywhere.
38 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
" As we sorrowfully walked back to the boat,
the captain, who was furious at the ruin we had
seen, told me that on his last trip he had carried
orders from Djevdet Bey to the soldiers that
the island and its inhabitants were to be left
unmolested. Evidently this was one of the
orders of which we heard more later, issued
with the additional information that the recipi-
ent was free to use his own judgment about
obeying it.
" The morning was not very far advanced
when the wind died down entirely, a very com-
mon occurrence on Lake Van, and the sailboats
were unable to go on. Leaving the sails un-
furled to catch any little breeze that might come
along, the sailors plied the heavy, clumsy oars
in a vain attempt to reach Tadvan, the seaport
of Bitlis, before night. Had it not been for the
motor-boat the poor men would have had to go
hungry all day, as all the bread for the trip was
on one boat. We went back and forth distribut-
ing bread, and then stopped the motor, for
strict orders had been given the captain that he
was to remain with the sailboats until they
reached their destination. Not a drop of water
had been provided for the journey, and as the
ACEOSS THE LAKE TO BITLIS 39
sun grew hotter the cries of the men that they
would die of thirst grew more and more insist-
ent. Finally the captain declared he could stand
it no longer, and, orders or no orders, he was
going for water. In a short time we reached
Tadvan, where he gathered up all the jugs he
could find in the town, filled them, and, leaving
us on shore, returned to the sailboats and their
passengers.
** Tadvan was full of soldiers, some of them
displaying and mocking at the crosses and other
dedicated things they had taken from the island
monastery. The villagers were frightened and
crowded around us. We tried to calm them by
saying that the government had assured us that
there would be no massacres in the Bitlis
province. Armenians, like the Van Armenians,
who, according to official report, had rebelled,
must be punished, but those who were loyal to
the government had nothing to fear. Some of
the people had escaped from near-by villages in
the Van province and their minds were full of
the horrors through which they had lived.
" The sailboats anchored at a village not far
from Tadvan. We went over there the next
day to do what we could for our patients while
40 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
waiting for ox-carts to take us to Bitlis. We
took up our abode in one end of a large stable,
billeted our men in village homes and fixed up
a place out-of-doors for dressing wounds. One
man was found whose arm had to be amputated
at once. We contrived a table just inside the
stable door from the two boxes which contained
instruments and other supplies. The man was
not very tall, but in order that his head might
rest on the ' table/ his legs had to hang over
the other end. The operation was successful.
" During the day Sister Martha and I were
startled by a strange sound that seemed to
come from behind a hill some distance away,
and drew nearer and nearer. Then a crowd of
fifty or more people appeared approaching the
village, half chanting, half wailing, in the pecul-
iar way Armenians have of showing grief and
telling their troubles. When they saw soldiers
about they left the road, sat down on the hillside
and, rocking back and forth, and wringing their
hands, they repeated over and over, after the
manner of their race, the story of the awful
massacre that had taken place in their village
the day before. Wives and mothers told how
their little babies had been killed and their
ACEOSS THE LAKE TO BITLIS 41
bodies thrown into the lake and others had been
thrown in alive, and how their attractive brides
and daughters had been carried off by the
Kurds. When they were calm enough to speak
coherently they said that the attacking party
had not been one of Turkish soldiers but of
Kurds who claimed to have come from the
Erzerum region and who said that the Russians
had carried off their sheep and cattle, and so
they were making good their losses by carrying
away the property of the Armenians. Russians
and Armenians were both Christians, so it was
all the same.
" There was but one man in this group of sur-
vivors, and he was badly wounded, as were most
of the women and some of the children. After
having their wounds dressed they went on their
way again towards Bitlis, where they expected
to complain to the government and demand pro-
tection and redress. They had no idea that the
affair had been ordered by the government.
" We were obliged to spend several days in
this village. One day we saw a small party of
Kurds evidently reconnoitering above the place.
A soldier was sent out to inquire their business,
and then they went back in the direction from
42 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
which they had come. They had come to raid
this village also, but postponed it on account of
our presence. They did not go far away, for we
were hardly out of sight on our return to Tad-
van before they began their work of murder
and destruction.
" Another night had to be passed in Tadvan.
The people were even more terror stricken than
before, and several crowded into the stable
where we spent the night, hoping for greater
protection. All night long we heard shooting
and were assured that it was only the soldiers
fighting to protect the Christian villagers from
attacking parties of Kurds.
" Our caravan during the last stage of our
journey to Bitlis consisted of several ox-carts
loaded as heavily as possible with boxes and
bedding, a patient or two on top, the weakest
bound on. It was fearful to watch the carts in
front of us lurching this way and that as the
wheels went over big stones or into ruts in
the road. The poor fellows with no strength to
help themselves cried out in fear. We were
powerless to help matters.
" We kept passing groups of mounted Kurds
going to or returning from their work of de-
ACEOSS THE LAKE TO BITLIS 43
struction. Upon the hillsides groups of men
were making trenches. At the entrance to the
city we were stopped and taken to a poHce sta-
tion, where a very careful account was recorded
of each one. Sister Martha and I were regis-
tered as ' German doctors.' The question of
how to dispose of us properly seemed to be an
embarrassing one until I announced that I was
an American and we expected to be cared for at
the American mission.
" We had sent a telegram the day before from
Tadvan telling of our coming, and Miss Ely and
Mr. Knapp had ridden out in the afternoon to
meet us. Naturally our failure to appear had
caused some little anxiety, and when we did ar-
rive, wet, hungry and exhausted, we received a
hearty welcome. No one who has not been
through a similar experience could possibly im-
agine what it meant to us to be once more in a
quiet Christian home, eating a well-cooked,
nicely served dinner after four weeks of con-
stant association with Turkish soldiers and
officers."
VI
TWELVE THOUSAND REFUGEES IN BITLIS
MISS McLaren and Sister Martha ar-
rived in Bitlis five days after the
departure of Mr. and Mrs. Maynard
and Miss Uline. In that short interval deporta-
tions and massacres had begun in the province,
and Armenians, mostly women and children,
driven from their homes by Kurds acting under
the orders of the government, began pouring
into the city. About seven hundred took refuge
on the American premises.
The compound was rather small and sur-
rounded by a high stone wall with gabled top.
A great arched gateway opened upon the street;
its huge, double-leaved wooden doors were
closed at night, barred with four heavy iron bars
and bolted with a wooden beam about six inches
square. This form of safeguarding homes or
schools was common throughout the city, and
windows everywhere were cross-barred with
inch-thick iron rods.
44
REFUGEES IN BITLIS 46
There were four buildings in this enclosure;
the large church, the girls' schoolhouse, the
boys* schoolhouse and the Maynards' residence,
occupied after their departure by Mr. Knapp.
Unfortunately the other missionary residence,
though very near the compound, was separated
from it by the right of way of a Turkish neigh-
bour so that its occupants had to pass through
the public street to schools, church and the
home of their associates, a procedure most in-
convenient and even unsafe in times of political
unrest.
This house had belonged to Rev. and Mrs.
George C. Knapp, who had been missionary
pioneers in Bitlis, and it had also been the
home of Miss Charlotte Ely for the greater
part of the forty-seven years she had spent in
this city. With her lived Miss Myrtle O. Shane,
now in charge of the girls* school, and Miss
McLaren and Sister Martha became her guests.
Reports came in every day of the destruction
of this village and that in the neighbourhood of
Bitlis. The Governor, when appealed to by the
missionaries, pretended to be greatly troubled
by all this lawlessness, which he attributed to a
noted Kurdish brigand, and declared he was
46 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
making every effort to put an end to it. Yet
crowds of old men, women and children con-
tinued to flee terror-stricken to Bitlis until there
were about 12,000 in the city. Some were cared
for in an Armenian church, and the chief priest
of the city had rehef funds which he distributed
every day. Eight thousand were allotted to the
Americans; Mr. Knapp soon used up what relief
funds he had and telegraphed Constantinople
for more. Even when this was received there
was only enough to allow each person a very
small sum daily, barely enough to keep her alive.
Many of these refugees were wounded; one
little fellow six or seven years old had four or
five wounds, some penetrating the lungs, made
by a dagger in the hand of a Moslem; a little
girl had her arm shattered by a Turkish bullet —
instances could be many times multiplied. The
superintendent of the hospital gave the neces-
sary supplies for treating these wounded people
and a place to house them. The "women's
hospital " was known to the police and so was
never molested, and the number of poor crea-
tures who sought refuge and healing increased
until larger quarters had to be found.
The wounded Turks brought from Van had
EEPUGEES IN BITLIS 47
been put into an old monastery outside the city,
but the arrangement did not prove satisfactory;
the monastery was turned into a convalescent
home and the surgical cases brought into Ar-
menian houses near the mission premises, from
which the owners were ejected. The chief doc-
tor sent orders that the Protestant church was
to be turned over to the hospital authorities at
once. Mr. Knapp refused to do this without a
written request from the VaH. Later, the mis-
sionaries invited the doctor to an afternoon tea
at the Ely residence, and when some of Miss
Ely's delicious cake had made him relax a little
from his unfriendly attitude, they formally of-
fered him the use of the church for hospital pur-
poses. Miss McLaren and Sister Martha con-
tinued to work among these patients as they
had in Van.
Early in June the refugees were gathered up
and driven through the streets by gendarmes.
From the bluff overlooking the southern road
great numbers of them could be seen herded to-
gether in readiness to be sent south.
" These ignorant village Armenians are not
fit to live — they ought to die/' said a Turkish
doctor to Mr. Knapp in the presence of all the
48 THE TEAGBDY OF BITLIS
Americans. And very soon reports were
brought back by women and children who es-
caped that the refugees were being killed by
Kurds on the road. One woman, fingers shot
off and a gash on her face, said that the gen-
darmes had told the party in which she was
taken that at a certain point farther on the
Kurds would attack them. This was not a
warning, for those who tried to escape were
shot down. Mr. Knapp and the native pastor
asked the Vali to allow these deported people to
go by the Moush road to avoid Kurdish attacks.
He replied that the Moush region was quiet and
must remain so.
There was an epidemic of typhus. Five or six
of the refugees on the mission premises died
every day; at first their bodies were buried in a
garden across the street, but later this was not
permitted and they had to be buried in the
mission compound. In digging these graves the
bones were unearthed of many who had lost
their lives in the massacre of 1895 and who had
been buried here to keep at least their dead
bodies inviolate from their murderers.
VII
MASSACRE OF THE MEN
THE government officials constantly as-
sured the Americans that only the vil-
lages near the border wert being
evacuated and that no harm would come to any
one in the city.
The Russians v^rere reported to be drav^ing
nearer every day; the authorities had made
their preparations to set fire to the principal
buildings and leave on short notice. A band of
Kurds from Motgan, notorious as men who had
always defied the government, came to the city
one day, and when they left each was equipped
with a modern rifle and plenty of ammunition.
Neither the Americans nor the Armenians
then suspected a massacre ordered by the gov-
ernment, but they had no doubts as to what the
Motgan Kurds would do as soon as the garrison
should be withdrawn. Armenians begged to be
allowed to come to the American premises for
protection. A general permission to do so
49
60 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
would inevitably have created a panic and pre-
cipitated trouble with the authorities, but the
famiUes of the pastor and teachers and a few
others were allowed to come quietly and others
were promised admittance in case of actual
danger. The condition was made that all fire-
arms of those admitted should be turned over
to Mr. Knapp.
On June 22d Rev. Khachig Vartanian, who
had been pastor of the Protestant church and
ofhcial representative of the Protestant commu-
nity before the government for many years, one
of the most influential and deeply respected citi-
zens of Bitlis, was seized and imprisoned while
on his way to the Vali on behalf of some refu-
gees.
On June 23d the American premises were sur-
rounded by armed soldiers and police. Mr.
Knapp was in the Maynard house, now his own
residence, and the four ladies in Miss Ely's
house. Feeling that if anything was going ta
happen her place was in the girls' school, Miss
Shane started to go there, but the guard at the
gate leading to the street forced her to return
at the point of a gun.
Officers and soldiers, armed to the teeth as if
MASSACEE OF THE MEN 51
they were after a band of robbers instead of a
few law-abiding Armenians, now appeared,
sought out and arrested every man and every
boy over ten years of age on the mission prem-
ises and Hned them up in the school-yard,
guarded by gendarmes as if they were criminals.
One soldier was stationed on the roof opposite,
where he kept jumping about like a monkey,
his gun constantly pointed at the group.
Resistance would have been worse than use-
less; the possession and use of firearms would
have sealed the fate not only of the men but of
the women and children. The latter crowded
around their husbands, brothers and fathers,
clinging to them and crying bitterly.
"Why do you make such a fuss? They are
only going to be examined about something.
Of course they are all innocent and will soon be
back," said the soldiers.
Mr. Knapp hurried to the Vali, taking Sister
Martha with him in the hope that a German
might get at the true meaning of the affair and
perhaps secure the men's release. The Vali re-
ceived them in his usual polite way, listened
quietly to their story and request and then said
that the government kn^w ^hat letters from the
62 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
enemy in Van had been received by some Ar-
menian or Armenians in Bitlis and the object of
arresting all the men was to discover who these
recipients were. When found, they would be
treated as traitors, while all others would be set
free as soon as their innocence was established.
No resistance would be tolerated; if any were
attempted it would put in immediate danger all
on the premises.
The men were marched off to prison. A good
old man, who had taught in the school for many
years, comforted his terrified pupils:
"Do not be afraid; they are persecuting us
for our religion, but we shall remain faithful to
Christ." A few boys were sent back as too
young.
Throughout the city men and boys were ar-
rested, on the street, in their shops, in their
homes. If a man resisted he was killed. Those
who hid themselves in their houses and refused
to come out were burned with their families.
On one occasion a man was discovered to be
hiding in a house, part of which was visible from
the windows of the girls' school. It was as if
hounds had scented a fox. Turks ran yelping
from all directions. Some climbed upon the flat
MASSACRE OF THE MEN 63
roof and leaned over with their guns pointing
downward in order to have a good chance at
him should he try to escape. The commotion
lasted about two hours, but Miss Shane, who
saw its beginning, did not see its end.
In one house where there was a large house-
hold, many sons living with their famiUes in
their fathers home, according to the patri-
archal custom of the country, there were ten
guns which were used with telling effect against
the police.
It was finally fired from the inside and some
of its inmates burned. The rest retired to the
cellar, where they had stored provisions and
water for a siege. The police soon found out
that there were people there still alive and be-
gan to try to get them out. Miss McLaren, hap-
pening to pass at the time, saw a lot of soldiers
on the street with their guns pointed towards
the building. Police with beams were trying to
batter down the cellar walls, always keeping out
of range from the windows. In the evening two
badly wounded little boys were brought from
that house to Sister Martha. The men had been
obliged to surrender at last. The father, a
lawyer who had been in the service of the gov-
54 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
ernment many years, was brought from the
prison to view the remains of his home and to
see what it meant for a subject to defy his gov-
ernment.
This was the strongest resistance to arrest in
the city. In most cases the men went quietly,
trusting that they would soon be released. The
government succeeded perfectly in deceiving
the people with its assurances. The Americans
also were more than once misled by its prom-
ises.
All the Armenian nurses, druggists and or-
derlies in the hospital were also taken. It mat-
tered not that they were the most intelligent
and faithful helpers, and that there was no one
left to prepare medicines for the Turkish pa-
tients— all had to go.
The first victim was a young man employed
in the military hospital, a graduate of Euphrates
College, Harpoot. He had tried to give his
friends at home some idea of the situation in
Bitlis by telling about the swarms of locusts that
had visited the province shortly before. His
allusion was understood by the censor, he was
arrested, marched off under guard, and a Kurd-
ish neighbour told the Americans that he was
MASSACRE OF THE MEN 56
taken only a short distance from the city and
there killed.
There were two Armenian surgeons in the
city, young men, earnest, faithful and enthusi-
astic over their work, not influenced in the per-
formance of their duties by the thought of what
was being done to their people. One morning
they told Sister Martha and Miss McLaren that
they had been ordered to go to Sert to take
charge of a hospital which Djevdet Bey was
starting there. A Turkish doctor later told the
missionaries that he had seen their bodies lying
by the roadside about six miles from the city.
Sister Martha and Miss McLaren had brought
with them from Van two Armenian boys who
had been working in the military hospital there
and for whom Sister Martha had secured from
the miHtary authorities papers insuring their
safety. When the Bitlis men were taken from
the city, one of these lads was ill in a hospital.
Sister Martha, hearing that he had been taken
out with the other Armenians, went to the chief
of police to inform him of these papers and to
ask that the boy might be sent back. The chief
said that he would send an order to this effect.
When she went to see him again he told her that
66 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
it was impossible to bring the boy back, as he
had been killed on the day that he was taken
out. His companion was spared.
For several days the Protestant women took
food to the prison and were allowed to talk
freely with the men who crowded around the
windows. The prisoners sent word to the mis-
sionaries that they had done right in not permit-
ting weapons on the mission premises; that the
whole afifair had been so fiendishly planned by
the government that there had been no chance
of escape for the men from the first; they were
praying that the efforts made to save the women
and children might succeed.
After a week of this the women were told one
morning that all the Protestants had been put
into an underground dungeon. Various stories
were heard later as to what happened to these
men, but all that was definitely known was that
they were taken out in groups and killed not far
from the city. One story, the truth of which
Mr. Knapp believed to be well established, was
that one group of TOO men was taken out to a
place about six miles from the city and lined up
on either side of trenches already prepared.
Kurds then came upon them and killed them.
MASSACEE OF THE MEN 57
Several of the men on the mission premises
had hidden during the first search and so es-
caped. One of these was Kevork Effendi Koo-
yoomjian, a graduate of Central College, Ain-
tab, and head teacher in the boys' school. But
he decided that he could not hope to save him-
self and that if he were discovered it might work
harm to the women and children under the care
of the missionaries. He had married but a few
years before one of the teachers in the girls'
school, a girl most attractive in person and
lovely in character. Their courtship had been
a romantic one, their betrothal not the usual
businesslike arrangement between two families,
but a real " love match." At her wedding,
Heghene, instead of being shrouded Oriental
fashion in a shapeless dark silk mantle, had
looked like an American bride with her lace veil,
orange-flower wreath and bridal bouquet — a
fair vision that had impressed itself upon the
imagination of all the young people who had
been present. Their short married life had been
a very happy one, except for the death of their
first child ; they had at this time a beautiful little
girl one year old.
The day after Kevork EflFendi had made his
58 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
decision the police sent word that they were
coming to search the American premises for
men who were in hiding. That morning the
young couple spent several hours alone to-
gether, then joined in the main room of the
school the others who meant to surrender, and
waited calmly the event that would too surely
separate them. She sat at his feet with the baby
in her arms.
" Miss Shane, if we should both be taken will
you not keep our baby? " asked Kevork Effendi.
When the police came he and his young
brother-in-law shook hands with their friends as
composedly as if they were merely going for a
walk, and no one seeing the sweet look of cour-
age on Deegeen Heghene's face would have
guessed that the man was her husband and the
boy her brother. Kevork EflFendi looked strong
and triumphant, for although he knew he was
going to his death, the night spent in prayer
had prepared him for his fate and he had no
fear. Had those around him had eyes to see
they would have beheld one whose form was
** like unto the Son of God,*' walking in the
fiery furnace beside him.
VIII
DEPORTATION OF THE WOMEN
^— »-^WO or three days after the men on the
■ American premises were taken to
1
prison the Vali told Mr. Knapp that an
order had come for a general deportation of
Armenians, but that families would be allowed
to go in safety together. Yet within a few days
(June 29th or 30th) the poHce began to hound
women and children out of their homes, insult-
ing and beating them cruelly and forcing by
kicks and blows and curses those who fell by the
wayside to get up and go on. A few escaping
and coming back with faces mutilated and hands
cut off substantiated the rumours concerning
the fate of those who were driven away. The
Americans, whose premises were still strictly
guarded, were not allowed to take these poor
creatures in, but could talk to them at the gate,
give them bread and a little money, and then
they would be gathered up and driven away
again.
59
60 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
Miss Shane had taken up her residence in the
girls' school where, besides her girls, there were
a number of women and children who had come
to her for protection. A day or two after their
deportation began she went with Miss McLaren
as interpreter to the Vali and requested that the
schoolgirls and the women with her in the
school building be allowed to remain. He said
that she might take her pupils to Harpoot and
put them in the school there. She knew that the
school buildings in Harpoot had been taken by
the government for hospital purposes, and that
the roads were covered with the bodies of the
dead ; she thought, too, of the fate of the women
and little children who would be left behind, and
replied that if he were sincere in assuring her
that she could take the girls safely to Harpoot
he would be willing to have them remajn quietly
in Bitlis till travelling was safer. He answered
that an order had come from Constantinople
that not an Armenian should remain in Bitlis;
the responsibility was not his.
" In that case I will not give them up," she
answered.
She meant to barricade the school building.
It seemed necessary to take a firm stand on this
DEPORTATION OF THE WOMEN 61
point, and neither she nor her associates be-
lieved that the authorities would proceed to ex-
tremes to get possession of these few women
and girls.
He finally consented to allow the girls and
women in the school to remain " until the last."
She asked to whom she might appeal to insure
their ultimate safety and he gave her the name
and address of the military commandant, who
had decided the matter in regard to the women.
This man was at the front with his army, so Miss
Shane immediately wrote to him, sending a
copy of the letter to the Vali together with the
list of her women and girls which he had de-
manded of her. To this letter no answer was
ever received.
The missionaries were obliged to promise
that no more people should be taken into the
compound and tried to keep this promise as
their only hope of saving a few.
The police seemed to have gone mad in their
thirst for Armenian blood. One day Miss Shane
saw from her window a white-haired old woman
stumbling along the street beneath a rain of
blows from a gendarme's gun. .A younger
woman, herself so weak she could scarcely walk,
62 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
was trying to support her. Suddenly the gen-
darme sprang in front of them and pointed his
bayonet at the old woman as if to run it through
her body. She fell in a heap at his feet. Where-
upon he seized her first by the girdle and then
by the hair and dragged her along the rough
street. She was left for dead near the girls'
school and they were allowed to take her in.
She had a sweet and gentle face and was found
to be a member of a well-to-do family. Officials
were very angry when they found how she had
been treated, for she was supposed to know
where a large sum of money was concealed and
they wanted it. The poor creature did not live
long enough to tell her secret.
Another old woman died in the school who
was found lying in the street outside with just
strength enough to Hft her hand slightly in an
eflFort to ward off a dog who was sniffing at her
face. Several times the missionaries were al-
lowed to bring inside those who were found in
a dying condition.
The screams of women and children could be
heard at almost any time during the day. The
cries that rang out through the darkness of the
night were even more heartrending.
DEPOETATION OF THE WOMEN 63
" Once," writes Miss Shane, " I was startled
from sleep by a woman's shriek of terror, fol-
lowed by cries and pleadings which were an-
swered only by the jeering laugh of men. For
about two hours I could hear the woman's low
moans, like those of a tortured animal. The
sound grew fainter and fainter and at last —
silence.
" One day I was watching a crowd of women
and children in the street below. They were
led by a gendarme to a spot just beneath the
window, then made to stop. A few women gave
money to the gendarmes and were then set free.
They ran frantically hither and thither like
frightened animals. Where could they go for
safety? There zvas no safety for them. The
fiendish grin on the face of the man who had
released them showed that he relished the sport.
This incident confirmed to my mind the report
that gendarmes accepted bribes from the women
who had a bit of money, but that these women
were captured again later and taken down the
road.
" By working quietly we had managed to take
in about thirty little children who had come
starving to our gates and the guards there had
64 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
not objected. The first few indeed had been
brought to us by Turkish soldiers. We felt
sure we should not be able to keep them but
would provide for them as long as possible.
One of these was the daughter of our teacher in
Tadvan. Her eyes had the deep blue of the sky
when a storm is threatening. She was always
quiet, but so sweet that she never passed un-
noticed, her little face so serious, so solemn. So
were the faces of all the little ones. One of the
things that impressed me most was that the
little children never smiled, always that look of
hurt wonder on their faces. In her quaint baby
fashion she once told the girls the name of the
Kurd who had killed her father, and added,
' May he die a death like that' She was taken
ill after a while and did not recover.
" Finally a policeman came to take these
orphans away. Among them was a little girl
between two and three years of age, a grand-
child in one of the best families in Bitlis. She
had the sweetest, most winning baby face I have
ever seen. We had all grown to love her.
When she was put in line with the others
I rushed forward, took her up in my arms
and begged to be allowed to keep her.
DEPOETATION OF THE WOMEN 65
The policeman refused. Her innocent, trust-
ful face would have melted a heart of stone.
She toddled along with the others, but be-
fore they reached the gate a Turk employed
in the hospital picked her up and was permitted
to keep her. The child, however, turned her
face from him and wriggled and twisted to get
out of his arms. He took her home and his fam-
ily tried to win her by kindness, but she was
obdurate. He finally gave her into the care of
one of our women.
" As far as I know, with but one exception,
the choice of accepting Islam was not given to
men and boys nor to the poorer classes of
women. However, many of those belonging to
wealthy families were urged to become Mos-
lems. Three women from the principal ward of
the city came to tell us that if they refused to
accept Islam they would be sent down the road.
One of these was the sister of a teacher in our
girls' school. I was later (when ill in bed) told
by one of my teachers that this woman had re-
fused to accept Islam and had been sent off with
her ten-year-old daughter, and that both had
been taken by Kurds; the mother had come
back to the school accompanied by a Kurdish
66 THE TRAGEDY OP BITUS
woman and asked her sister for ten liras, saying
that the Kurds had threatened to kill her daugh-
ter if she did not give that much money, but if
she gave it she would be allowed to take her
daughter away. She received the money, went
away and was never heard of again.
" Some time after my illness I was calling on
a Turkish officer's wife; she and her husband
had shown kindness to Armenians and were
friendly to us. She said they had found that
little ten-year-old girl wandering in the streets
half naked and in a terrible condition, having
been maltreated in most inhuman fashion.
They had taken her in and were having an old
Armenian woman take care of her. She said
also that they themselves were out of favour
with the government because of their lack of
sympathy with the way in which Armenians
were being treated and therefore were being
sent to Aleppo.
" A little innocent-faced lad, one of our school-
boys who had found his way back to our prem-
ises during the evacuation of the city, told me
that he was one of a large party of women and
children driven down the road. He had escaped
a short distance from the city and came back to
DEPOETATION OF THE WOMEN 67
the house of a friendly Turk. The Turk, how-
ever, insisted on his becoming Moslem, so he
ran away. Before his escape on the road he had
seen a young woman who was carrying a baby
shot down because she had not strength to keep
up with the others. Her body was left lying
where it fell, the baby still in her arms.
" One of our pupils, a girl, was sent to prison,
but later was released and allowed to go back to
the house of Mustifa Bey, superintendent of
hospitals, where she had been staying. She told
me that the prison was crowded with women
and children kept there without food or water.''
Many women were kept in the courtyard of
an Armenian church, others in a large house
just across the street from the American prem-
ises and still others were herded together like
cattle in an open field between the public high-
way and the river at a place called the " Arab
Bridge," not far from the city. Soldiers were
stationed near by to guard them. There was no
shelter, no privacy. Day after day these women,
many of them accustomed to comfort if not lux-
ury in their homes, were kept there in the hot
July sun and entirely at the mercy of the beasts
who guarded them. A few managed to escape
68 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
by bribing the guards, or under cover of the
night, and the stories they told the missionaries
of their sufferings at the hands of the soldiers
were too awful to repeat.
After a while the young and attractive women
were taken into Turkish or Kurdish homes and
the rest sent " down the road," most of them to
death. Many threw themselves and their chil-
dren into the river to escape the suffering and
abuse they were unable to endure longer.
Some of the prominent citizens had provided
their families with poison, which they took
rather than fall into the hands of the Turks.
Other women with their children refused to
leave their burning houses, counting that kind
of death preferable to life in a Turkish harem.
The thirteen-year-old daughter of Pastor
Khachig, seeing a bottle marked " Poison " in
Miss McLaren's room, told the women in the
house, " There is a bottle of poison in Miss
McLaren's room, and if the Turks try to take
me away I am going to drink some."
The deportation of the women began the first
week in July. It continued for months with
but one week's interruption.
IX
THE RUSSIAN ARMY APPROACHES
THE Russian army, after its occupation
of Van, moved slowly westward, meet-
ing with stubborn resistance at many
points. The motor-boat which had brought
Miss McLaren and Sister Martha across the
lake and one of the large sailboats were loaded
at Tadvan with ammunition to be taken back
to the Turkish army. They were ordered first
to Vostan, a town about seven hours from Van,
from there ordered back across the lake to a
village called Surp, not far from Tadvan and
near to where a battle was to be fought.
On arrival at Surp the captain and his brother
went to report to the authorities, leaving the
boats in charge of two Armenian boatmen, with
two guards on shore. The boatmen shot the
guards with the captain's gun and sailed back to
the Russians with the ammunition.
69
70 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
The people of the village of Avantz, the sea-
port of Van, were mostly sailors, and whether
from choice or by compulsion had been most
faithful in their service to the government. Had
it not been for them the Turks would never
have been able to transport their hospital pa-
tients and equipment across the lake and many
of the civil population would have been unable
to flee towards Bitlis before the advancing
enemy. When the general massacre of April
19th took place in Van province this place was
left untouched. Of course the Turks reaHzed
how much depended upon the loyalty of these
villagers. At the time of the incident related
above they had no further use for the boats and
sailors, and saying that they must have revenge
for the murder of the two soldiers and the loss
of the ammunition, they gathered together all
the boatmen who could be found in Tadvan and
drowned them in the lake.
About the middle of July the Russian army
drew very near to Bitlis ; those living on the out-
skirts of the city could hear the firing. The
Moslem population fled. The Governor sent
word to the Americans that they would have to
go. But as Miss Shane was ill at the time, they
THE EUSSIAN AEMY APPEOACHES 71
decided to remain. They had been constantly
exposed to typhus, and Miss Shane had fallen
ill on July 4th.
It may be noted in passing, that at this very
time five of the missionaries in Van also fell ill
of typhus which they had contracted from Mos-
lem refugees, one thousand of whom they cared
for on their premises after the Russian occupa-
tion. But there was absolutely no communica-
tion between the two cities; the Americans in
each were quite ignorant of the condition of
their friends in the other.
Many Moslems when they fled left with the
missionaries the women and girls whom they
had taken into their harems, an action that
seemed to show that their intentions in the first
place had been kind.
Other women who had so far escaped capture
also fled to the Americans for protection from
the Kurds, who were swarming into the city for
plunder, knowing that before the arrival of the
Russians they could flee back to safe retreats in
the mountains.
" We told them that the Governor had for-
bidden our taking any more Armenians in, but
that it seemed now the Governor himself would
72 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
be leaving shortly and if they cared to take their
chance with us, we would do what we could, but
if the government should demand them we
could probably not prevent their being taken.
They said that if they remained in the city they
would undoubtedly fall victims to the Kurds and
would take their chance with us."
Even the soldiers fled. The Turkish patients
who could be moved were sent off towards Diar-
bekir, and the others were brought to the Prot-
estant church and the English Consulate (a
near-by building which had once been the Con-
sulate), and were given over to the care of Mr.
Knapp and Sister Martha. American flags were
put up over the buildings for protection. Later,
one of the accusations brought against Mr.
Knapp was that he had put up flags to guide
the enemy.
There was a branch of the Ottoman bank in
Bitlis. The bankers, a Greek and an Italian,
afraid to remain in the business district on ac-
count of the Kurds, left it and came to stay
with Mr. Knapp. The danger was so great that
the Vali, who was still in the city with a few
ofificers and soldiers, was asked for a guard and
gave it. The bankers watched half of the night
THE RUSSIAN ARMY APPROACHES 73
and Mr. Knapp the other half for a week. Then
the bankers left the city, telling the Americans
before they did so that they (the Americans)
were in great danger of being attacked by
Kurds at the instigation of the government to
prevent their giving information to the enemy.
Sister Martha was free to act independently
of the Americans, of course, and the Turks took
for granted that she would leave with the hos-
pital authorities. She had great fears of becom-
ing a prisoner of the Russians and the Ameri-
cans supposed she would go. One morning she
came to Miss Shane, whom she had been nurs-
ing, and said, " I've made my decision. Mustifa
Bey just came on his horse and was surprised
that I was not ready to go, but I told him I
wasn't going. Whatever may be my fate in
Russia I will not go one step farther with the
Turks."
A few hours after it was reported that the
Vali was on the point of leaving, the news was
brought that the Russians were retreating.
Word was immediately sent out to the fleeing
populace to return and by the 24th the Turks
were back again.
THE PASSING OF MISS CHARLOTTE ELY
THE shock of these events proved too
great for Miss Charlotte Ely, now in
her seventy-sixth year, to endure. She
did her utmost to relieve and comfort the people
she loved, spending much of her time among
the village refugees, of whom many had once
been her pupils, listening to their stories and
praying for them most wonderful prayers. But
she suffered so intensely through her sympathy
with them that body and mind weakened under
the strain ; she sank into a state of unconscious-
ness at last, from which she rallied only once or
twice, and on July 11th she passed beyond all
care and sorrow.
Charlotte and Mary Ely, daughters of an
American clergyman and a gifted English
mother, were born in America and spent their
childhood in Philadelphia. Early orphaned,
they were given a home and a very unusual edu-
cation for those days by their uncle, Ezra S.
74
Charlotte E. El>
Alzina Churchill Knapp
Mary A. C. Ely
Georgc Perkins Kiiapp
THE PASSING OF MISS CHARLOTTE ELY 75
Ely, of Buffalo. He sent them to Elmira Col-
lege and to Mt. Holyoke Seminary, whence they
graduated with the " war class " of *61, then
sent them abroad. Charlotte studied music un-
der famous masters in Heidelberg, both studied
languages in Germany and France, visited Italy,
where they met Garibaldi, and made the ac-
quaintance of their mother's family in England.
At the end of two years they returned to
America. On the home-going steamer they be-
came acquainted with Rev. and Mrs. George C.
Knapp, from Turkey, and this proved to be a
turning point in their lives, for their hearts were
deeply touched by what Mrs. Knapp had to tell
them of the narrow, meager, burdened lives of
Oriental women and of the little school she had
started for girls in Bitlis. Charlotte promised
to find a teacher for this school, but before long
she decided to be herself that teacher; her sister
came independently to the same conclusion, and
the two joined the Knapps on their return to
Bitlis in 1868.
From the first they were charmed with the
romantic situation of that isolated mountain
city and became so deeply in love with their
work there that they could not be induced to
76 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
leave it, though more than once Charlotte,
noted for her executive and administrative abil-
ity, v^as asked to become the head of much
larger schools in (seemingly) more important
missions. One v^inter she consented to take
charge of the school in Van, but she could be
torn av^ay from her Bitlis home, even for needed
rest and change, only against her v^ill. In her
forty-seven years of missionary life she re-
turned to America but twice, and in 1915 had
not had a furlough for eighteen years. A
woman of private fortune, many friends, culti-
vated tastes, love for the best in music, art, lit-
erature, great capacity for enjoyment, she gave
up without regret all that civilization offered
her, buried herself in this remote corner of
Kurdistan and devoted all her powers to the
service of its people.
The sisters developed Mrs. Knapp's school
into ''The Mt. Holyoke Seminary of Bitlis.'*
Girls from the most primitive, sordid village
homes ; girls from homes of material prosperity
but mental and spiritual vacuity; wild, ignorant
girls who had worked like beasts of burden in
the fields; girls bejewelled and petted whose
outlook was early marriage to strangers of their
THE PASSING OF MISS CHABLOTTE ELY 77
parents' choosing, and responsibilities for which
they were totally unfitted — these were taken in,
trained to obedience, self-control, truth-telling,
thrift and neatness, brought into intimate asso-
ciation with these two wonderful women and
surrounded with an atmosphere of love and
prayer. Character was what the Elys were
striving for; with infinite patience they hewed
and chiselled till the rough shapeless marble
took on form and beauty under their hands ; into
those young lives they poured the rich treasures
of their own hearts and minds and souls ; their
graduates became noble women whose influence
as teachers, wives and mothers civilized and
Christianized the communities in which they
lived.
Mary Ely was no whit behind Charlotte in
her self-forgetful devotion to her work, and to
this she added a peculiar devotion to her sister.
Hers was a more practical temperament; the
financial management of the school and the
charge of its domestic department fell to her
share ; common sense characterized her, shrewd
insight into character, a sincere humility, a
tender love for the weak or suffering and espe-
cially for little children.
78 THE TEAGEDT OF BITLIS
The efforts of the sisters were not confined
to the Seminary. They toured the villages
frequently, establishing and superintending
secondary schools and organizing work for
women everywhere.
To all this was added the management of
orphanages after the massacres of 1895-96.
This meant more than feeding, clothing, train-
ing and teaching the homeless waifs gathered
in from the street; it meant providing for their
future when they reached maturity, choosing
good husbands for them, and seeing to it that
they were well treated in their new homes.
Many a betrothal was solemnized in the Elys'
parlour; many a modest trousseau they pre-
pared with motherly solicitude and truly femi-
nine pleasure in the task.
For a good many years after Mrs. Knapp's
departure from Bitlis Miss Charlotte had the
charge, also, of the boarding department of the
boys' school. She was as successful in the
management of boys as of girls, thoroughly
understanding boy nature and skillful in deaHng
with it, and many a capable and useful preacher,
teacher, man of business, has affectionately
acknowledged that the good in him he owed to
THE PASSING OP MISS CHAELOTTE ELY 79
Mire-Varzhoohee*s (Mother-Teacher's) care
and guidance.
She planned her school buildings and super-
vised their erection; minutely supervised the
work of carpenters, masons, gardeners, etc., in
her employ, teaching them new methods and
the accuracy foreign to the Oriental mind.
Hers was a many sided personality; contrasted
with her great strength of character and almost
masculine abilities were peculiar weaknesses
due to an extremely nervous, intense, sensitive
temperament. The fear of high winds, thunder-
storms and earthquakes was an acute torment
all her life, and every time she crossed the ocean
she was almost beside herself with terror
throughout the voyage. Yet she continued to
live where earthquakes were of common occur-
rence and where she was separated by that
dreaded ocean from her early home and friends
and relatives, because she loved her work witK
all her heart and soul.
In her wonderful memory was stored not
only the names of all her boys and girls, of her
neighbours and of the members of the Protes-
tant community, but also an immense amount
of detail concerning their characters and per-
80 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
sonalities, their relationships and the main
events in their Hves.
Both sisters identified themselves wholly with
the interests of their people and possessed their
unbounded confidence and affection. Moslems
as well as Christians trusted and revered
them.
Mary Ely fell ill in the fall of 1912. Dr.
Ussher, hastily summoned from Van, pro-
nounced her trouble heart disease, advised a
lower altitude, and took her to Mardin, where
she spent the winter under the care of Dr.
Thom. At first she improved in health, but
later grew worse and sea-level and the care of a
specialist seemed necessary. She would allow
no one to inform Charlotte of her condition, but
Miss Uline, one of her associates at Bitlis,
obliged at this time (April) to go to Beirut on
business, joined her at Mardin and the two
travelled together to the sea-coast.
Arrived in Beirut, Mary Ely sank rapidly.
The habit of sparing her idolized sister all
possible anxiety persisted to the last. She sent
word that she was comfortable and well cared
for and that Charlotte was on no account to
come to her. She would not permit physicians
THE PASSING OF MISS CHARLOTTE ELY 81
and nurses to telegraph the whole truth. On
May 5, 1913, she peacefully fell asleep in the
arms of the beloved young friend who had most
tenderly cared for her during those last days
of weakness and pain.
Very bravely did Miss Charlotte bear her loss
and loneliness, but half her life seemed gone.
And now that her spirit had taken flight her
pupils dressed her in the gown she had worn
at her graduation from Mt. Holyoke and she
was laid to rest in the garden she had tended
for many years. Only a few Armenians were
allowed to attend the funeral service. After-
wards one of the teachers said, " To think
that she who had taught us so many lovely
songs should be laid away without one song
from her Armenian girls, and that she who
had given her life to the Armenian people
should have to be carried to her grave by
strange Turkish soldiers ! "
Yet this very end, strange and sad as it seems,
significantly sealed the renunciations of her
lifetime. And who can doubt that she was
greeted in the new life by the " new song ** on
the lips of her Armenian girls, gone before her
up " the steep ascent of Heaven through peril,
toil and pain " ?
XI
AFTER THE RUSSIAN RETREAT
WHEN they had been waiting hourly
for word that the Governor and the
few remaining officers were leaving,
the Americans had got everything in readiness
to barricade their buildings against an attack
by Kurds. A young Armenian who came to
them disguised as a woman was allowed to stay
on condition he deliver up his firearms. He
was also forbidden to enter the girls' school.
Shortly after the retreat of the Russians and
while the Turks were returning to the city two
mounted gendarmes rode into the school prem-
ises. Mr. Knapp asked them what they wanted.
" That is our business."
" These are American premises and you have
no right to come in this way without an order.**
"You are the man we want; you come
with us."
They drew their guns to force him to accom-
82
AFTEE THE EUSSIAN EETEEAT 83
pany them. Mr. Knapp carried no arms: it
will be remembered that the Armenian men ad-
mitted to the premises early in June had been
asked to give up their arms and he would not
assume a privilege refused to them. Just out-
side the school gate they encountered a soldier
who protested against their action and while the
controversy was on Mr. Knapp left them and
went on to the Ely residence.
The incident seemed significant in the light
of an experience of his following the massacres
of 1896 (see Chapter XIV), and he told Miss
Shane there was a possibility of his being
obliged to leave.
A few days later officers came and asked him
to accompany them to a neighbouring house
as they had an official communication to make
to him, and they threatened to use force if he
did not immediately accede to their request.
Miss McLaren, at that time nursing Sister
Martha, who was ill with typhus, heard of this
and made up her mind to go with him.
" Escorted to a room where there were sev-
eral civil and military officials, we were given
the 'highest seats in the synagogue.* The
spokesman as I remember was the chief of
84 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
police, and he began by telling us that as for-
eigners living in Turkish territory we were the
honoured guests of the Ottoman Government
and as such entitled to all the protection they
could provide. Bitlis was in the war zone and
therefore we must move to safer quarters. It
was then four o'clock in the afternoon, and we
were to be ready to leave at seven the next
morning. Miss Shane was to go also. In vain
I pleaded for permission to remain as long as
Sister Martha lived. No, they had hospitals
and she could be cared for in one of them. In-
dignation and wrath increased as I listened, and
then I gave them my opinion of Turkish grati-
tude that would permit them to treat thus
lightly the care of one who was dying because
of what she had done for their soldiers. They
looked at me in amazement (perhaps in amuse-
ment) but repeated that I could not stay. As
there seemed nothing further to be said or done,
I went back to my patient, feeling sure that I
would stay with her until the end, but not know-
ing how it was to be brought about."
The officers told Mr. Knapp that they wished
to look over the premises and see how many
people were still there. The persecution of
AFTER THE RUSSIAN RETREAT 85
defenseless women and children had been re-
sumed immediately on the return of the Turks
and gendarmes had come to take away those
who, when the city had been practically evacu-
ated, had come to the American premises for
protection from the plundering Kurds (see
Chapter IX). Word was sent Miss Shane that
those who had been with her in the school from
the first (the sixty or seventy who had been
listed) would not be molested. Unable to re-
main quietly in bed, however, in this critical
situation. Miss Shane dressed hurriedly and
went across the hall to where the women and
girls were congregated. Mr. Knapp, down-
stairs, was urging the gendarmes to leave the
women where they were, but they declared they
were under orders and must take them.
Suddenly a shot rang out; Mr. Knapp and
two gendarmes ran up into the hall but finding
all quiet on the second floor went below and dis-
covered that the shot had been fired from a
window in the kitchen. Some of the women
upon the arrival of the gendarmes had taken
into the schoolhouse the young man who had
come to the premises a week earlier disguised
as a woman; he had somehow succeeded in
86 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
securing a gun, had concealed himself and,
thinking perhaps that a thorough search would
be made, had aimed at and wounded a soldier.
He must have been half-crazed with fear or he
would have known that such a foolhardy action
could only insure his own capture and would
endanger the safety of all the rest.
The Turks, fearfully enraged, surrounded
Mr. Knapp in the small entry leading to the
kitchen, levelling their guns at him. Miss
Shane, hearing from the women that he was in
great danger, made her way down-stairs, cling-
ing to the rail. Mr. Knapp, on seeing her, called
to her to go back, adding that they were in-
sisting on his entering the kitchen to disarm the
Armenian. One of the gendarmes ordered her
away. She went on. A policeman who seemed
to be in command then motioned her away;
when she refused to go he raised his gun to
strike her, his face distorted with wrath.
Realizing the uselessness of attempting to op-
pose him further, she turned to go up-stairs.
He barred the way, speaking rapidly in Turkish,
not a word of which could she understand, then
called a common soldier and indicated that she
was to follow him. She learned later that she
AFTEE THE EUSSIAN EETEEAT 87
was thus sent away because they intended to
burn the building to prevent the escape of the
Armenian.
As Mr. Knapp approached the kitchen door
another shot rang out; entering, he found the
young man dead by his own hand.
Meanwhile Miss Shane was taken to a large
house across the way which was being used as a
hospital. The principal of the girls' school
joined her before she reached the gate, and
when Miss Shane sank weak and exhausted into
a chair placed for her in one of the hallways, she
sat beside her supporting her, and began to
scold vigorously the Turks who occasionally
passed them, because Miss Shane had been
forced to leave the schoolhouse in her weakened
condition.
The two women were allowed to remain in
this hallway safe and unmolested, as Turks not
acting under government orders did not as a
rule concern themselves with whatever might
be going on. Indeed, in many instances they
had ere this shown regret that such things must
be. The women and girls in the schoolhouse
were brought over to this hospital; later, word
was sent to Miss Shane that she might go back
88 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
to the schoolhouse, for the building would not be
burned now that the young Armenian was dead.
Meanwhile several of the officers had gone
immediately after the shooting incident to Miss
McLaren in the Ely house.
" I had heard the shot and had seen the body
being dragged away, but knew nothing further.
The enraged men proceeded to enlighten me by
saying that Mr. Knapp had hidden that man
purposely to shoot one of them. I tried to con-
vince them that this was not true, giving as
proofs the facts that we had refused to allow
armed men on the premises, and that Mr. Knapp
had disarmed several. This statement, instead
of establishing our innocence, had the opposite
effect.
" * Where are the arms that he took? '
" * They are locked up in his safe.'
" ' Why did he not turn them over to us at
once? See, he keeps arms on the American
compound ! We must have them at once,* and
they arose to go.
" I did not see fit to tell them that under the
couch on which some of them had been sitting
there were two guns with ammunition, put there
for use in case of an attack by Kurds if the gov-
AFTER THE RUSSIAN RETREAT 89
ernment had been obliged to leave the city.
While they were gone, however, I had the guns
taken out and put in a less suspicious place,
ready to be handed over on demand. On their
return all looked as if they had unearthed a
great plot against the government and had
escaped a great danger. I helped them to
search our house for weapons and then renewed
my plea that I be allowed to remain, saying that
they might do with me what they liked after
Sister Martha was gone.
" Referring again to what they chose to call
Mr. Knapp's perfidy, they said I must go. Just
at that time the superintendent of the hospitals,
Mustifa Bey, walked in and asked what the
trouble was. On being told he pointed to me
and asked, * Is she going too? I need her in
my hospital. She does not belong to Bitlis, but
came over from Van with us and I cannot run
my hospital without her.' Neither he nor I be-
lieved this last, but it put matters in a new
light, and after a little whispered consultation
it was decided that I might remain. The doctor
also put in a word for Miss Shane and per-
mission was given her to remain until her
temperature came down to normal."
90 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
The gendarmes and soldiers withdrew from
the premises with the exception of the usual
guard. There was no sleep for any of the
Americans that night. The next morning it
was found that the women and girls in the house
across the way had been left unmolested, but
it was still reported that they would be taken
from the city later in the day. Permission was
given Miss Shane to see them.
" Supported by two of our women, I made
my way across the street and to the part of the
building where they were being held. The
pastor's wife rushed into the room, sank at my
feet and buried her face in my lap. The others
crowded about me. I told them that I had sent
word to Mustifa Bey, the superintendent of hos-
pitals, to intercede for them.
" Those were sad moments for all of us as we
knew what the future might hold in store for
them. For the most part they were calm and
quiet, and most earnest were the prayers that
went up as we knelt together.
" I was allowed to remain only fifteen min-
utes. Just before I left three soldiers came into
the room and tried to persuade several of the
girls to go with them to another room to do
AFTEE THE EUSSIAN EETEEAT 91
some work for them. The girls refused and the
men did not insist. One young woman, urged
more than the others, turned on the soldier and
with fearless eyes full of scorn said, * You can
kill me here but I will not go.' This was the
spirit of the girls, shown on various occasions,
and I was proud of them.
" Up to this time I had been staying in the
girls* school. But it seemed that Mr. Knapp
would leave that day and as all our girls and
women might be sent away at any time, he in-
sisted that, owing to my weak condition, I
should go back to the Ely residence.
" In the evening Mustifa Bey came in to tell
us that the girls would be allowed to stay. He
said that the Governor expressed himself as be-
ing sorry that matters had turned out as they
had, that he had not intended my girls to be
troubled in any way, but since the shooting on
our premises investigation was likely to be
made from Constantinople, and he could allow
them to remain only on condition that they
assist in the hospital.
" Mr. Knapp was allowed to do his packing
and no limit placed on the amount he could take
with him. Monday afternoon he came in to
92 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
give me the station books and advise me as to
the managing of affairs after his departure. At
ten o'clock he came in to say good-bye to us.
He was very sad and depressed, more on ac-
count of having to leave us alone in that critical
situation than on his own account, although he
was of the opinion that he would not be al-
lowed to travel safely. For a long time he had
been under intense strain, practically working
alone. He seemed never to think of himself
and had never wavered in his self-sacrificing
devotion and service to those under his protec-
tion. He was greatly troubled now because he
had allowed the young man to come into the
premises. But I reminded him that the re-
sponsibility was not his only, nor was any one
at fault. We could not foresee that the Rus-
sians would retreat or that the Armenian would
secure firearms and do the insane thing that he
had done.
" Before he left the house we had prayers to-
gether. Some time past midnight I heard the
soft tread of camels and horses in the street be-
low, and knew that he was on his way — alone."
And the two American women were left with
their dying friend.
XII
SISTER MARTHA
ONCE when Sister Martha had pleaded
in vain for a sick boy that he might be
allowed to remain in the compound un-
til he recovered instead of being taken away
from the city to his death — as she knew, a Turk-
ish officer took her aside and said, " Why do
you mix in this business? This is an American
home and you are a German ; you may get into
trouble ; keep away."
Her reply was, " Even if I am a German, this
is as much my business as the Americans' and I
won't keep away as long as I think I can help
the Armenians."
The Turks talked with her freely about their
treatment of the Armenians, expecting her to
see the matter from their point of view because
she was a German, and constantly reminded her
that they were allies. They went so far as to
say that Germany was responsible for the
massacres and hardly a day passed that some
93
94 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
Turkish official did not step up to her, put his
forefingers together and say, " We are brothers,
we are allies." Such remarks seemed little
short of sacrilege to her, for she believed the
Kaiser incapable of doing wrong.
" Oh ! " she would say to the Americans, " we
love our Kaiser. He would not do such things."
Later she evidently began to suspect, or had
reason to believe, that Germany was responsible
for the massacres, and this belief broke her
heart. Physically she had suffered greatly for
many months though she had never permitted
her health to interfere with her work; mentally
she now suffered even more keenly because of
her sympathy with the Armenians and her love
for her fatherland. The strain was too great
for her to bear; she often said to Miss McLaren,
" I want to go home. Not to my home in
Konigsberg but to my Father's home." And
every morning before going to her work she
would sing the hymn, " Ich mochte Heim."
Her desire was soon fulfilled. She fell ill with
typhus and from the first there seemed to be no
chance of her recovery. In her delirium she
would scream " Herrlichkeit! " then add in a
lower voice, "Ja Vater, du weiz." Miss Mc-
SISTER MARTHA 95
Laren nursed her throughout her illness and
wrote at her dictation little loving messages to
her friends and relatives. After ten days of in-
tense suffering she entered her " Father's
Home " on July 29, 1915.
There was no one in the city, Moslem or
Christian, who could make even a rough box for
a coffin, so Miss McLaren took a bier used for
carrying Turkish soldiers to the grave, cleansed
it, lined it and made it more fit for her purpose.
She conducted the burial service which Miss
Shane, two doctors and a few Armenian women
and girls attended.
No notice was taken by the Turkish Govern-
ment of Sister Martha's death, although she had
given her life for its soldiers. A few weeks
later the Vali asked Miss McLaren who Sister
Martha was, as an inquiry about her had come
from the German ambassador. Miss McLaren
had good reason to believe that he never took
the trouble to answer this inquiry.*
*See Chapter XV.
XIII
THE PIONEER PARENTS OF GEORGE
PERKINS KNAPP
ONE October morning in 1855 a newly
married couple set out from New Eng-
land on what proved a unique wedding
journey. They were to sail across the Atlantic
and the Mediterranean, but they had no sooner
left port than a terrific storm arose; the first
mate was washed overboard; the voyage lasted
so much longer than expected that before its
end the water and food supply was exhausted;
crew and passengers secured drinking water by
setting vessels out on deck to catch the rain.
Worst of all, the captain was drunk when the
ship reached the ^gean Sea and there was no
other officer capable of navigating the ship
through the dangerous archipelago.
There were seven missionaries on board : the
newly married pair, George Gushing Knapp and
96
THE PARENTS OF GEORGE P. KNAPP 97
his wife Alzina Churchill Knapp, Rev. and Mrs.
Edward Aiken, Rev. and Mrs. O. P. Allen and
Dr. H. B, Haskell. The four men were fresh
from theological seminary or medical school
and had never set foot on a sailing vessel be-
fore, but they were equal to the emergency:
locking the drunken captain into his cabin they
took the chart, studied it, and navigated the
ship successfully to port.
At Smyrna the seven travelling companions
separated. Dr. Haskell carried on medical
work in Mosul for a while ; the wife ^ he married
two years later, who visited Bitlis and became
a warm friend of the Knapps, is still living. Mr,
and Mrs. Aiken joined the mission at Beirut
and Mr. and Mrs. Allen were stationed at Har-
poot and a son and a daughter of theirs also
became missionaries in Turkey. Mr. Allen,
the last survivor of this little group, died in
Constantinople in the spring of 1918.
Mr. and Mrs. Knapp joined what was then
called the Assyrian Mission, and were stationed
in Diarbekir with Rev. and Mrs. Augustus
Walker and Dr. and Mrs. David O. Nutting.
In 1858, however, they begged to be permitted
* Mrs. S. B. Tibbals of New Haven.
98 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
to establish a station in a city whose need had
greatly appealed to them during a summer spent
there away from the great heat of the Diarbekir
plain.
BitHs is situated on a plateau so high and so
abrupt that in six hours of horseback travel one
can pass from a region of heavy winter snows
to a land of perpetual summer. It is the " door
between highlands and lowlands," as the valley
of the Bitlis River is the avenue of communica-
tion between the plateaus of the northeast and
east and the Mesopotamian plains.
The houses are built of large hewn blocks of
a sort of lava which is silvery gray and soft
enough to be cut with a knife when fresh from
the quarry, but turns hard and brown after long
exposure to the weather. Earthquakes have
been very frequent; in 1906 a series of earth-
quakes of unusual severity did much damage in
the villages of the region, but the houses of
Bitlis with their three-foot-thick stone walls
were injured in but few cases. Near the city
is an extinct volcano, Nimroud Dagh, which has
a crater second in size only to Crater Lake,
Oregon.
Mr. Knapp immediately started a class for
THE PARENTS OF GEORGE P. KNAPP 99
young men which met every evening at his
home. Mrs. Knapp taught daily a class of girls
and women. Mr. Trowbridge was their asso-
ciate the first winter; the next they were left
alone. The opposition of the jealous, ignorant
Gregorian priesthood was very severe at first
and at one time a mob set upon Mr. Knapp and
his helpers in the market-place. Dr. and Mrs.
Nutting were with them for a while in 1860 and
that summer the two men explored a field which
included two hundred towns and villages, of
which one hundred and twenty-eight were
Armenian. But this explored region was less
than half of the territory, fifteen hundred square
miles in area, belonging to Bitlis " station " and
the missionaries in Bitlis must evangelize this
territory if it was to be evangelized at all.
Rev. and Mrs. Lysander T. Burbank joined
them in 1861 and remained nine years. After
their departure the Knapps and the Misses Ely,
whom they had brought back with them on
their return from furlough in 1868, were the
only missionaries in this great field for fourteen
years.
The work was a pioneer work indeed. The
people were amazingly ignorant and geographic-
100 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
ally and chronologically remote from civiliza-
tion. There were no railroads in Kurdistan ; no
post horses, even, came to Bitlis in the sixties,
and the Americans had to send a man once a
month to Erzerum for their mail. People lived
and laboured as their ancestors had done before
them for hundreds of years. Women were
despised, overworked, led lives of dreary, slavish
subjection. The almost incredible ignorance of
mothers, the absence of any medical help what-
soever, the lack of sanitation, were the causes
of a seventy-five per cent infant mortality and
an immense amount of physical suffering, de-
formity and blindness.
The American missionaries educated girls as
well as boys — an unheard of, and at first bitterly
opposed, experiment. They sought first of all
to build up strong helpful Christian characters.
Knowledge, a wider outlook, new ideals, new
ambitions, the personal influence and example
of these American teachers, gradually raised the
whole level of civilization in the region. Homes
like those of Pastor Khachig and his wife,
Kevork Effendi's and Deegeen Heghene's —
cultured, happy, love-filled homes; characters
like theirs that bore triumphantly the supreme
THE PARENTS OF GEORGE P. KNAPP 101
test at the last, were the bright flowering of this
new civilization.
For this work Mr. and Mrs. Knapp were pe-
culiarly fitted : the pioneer blood of six genera-
tions of New England ancestry ran in their
veins; theirs was the resourcefulness, ambition
and " grit *' that seems the heritage of those
born and bred on New England farms; and
theirs a whole-hearted, enthusiastic devotion to
the service of their Master.
Mr. Knapp had the true Yankee ingenuity,
inventiveness and mechanical ability. He taught
his pupils to make the furniture of their school-
room, and helped them pay their way with the
work of their hands. He introduced the use of
window-glass, and dark germ-breeding dwell-
ings were thus opened to the purifying sunlight.
He planted a garden, raising in it many vege-
tables unknown to that region, two of which,
the potato and tomato, became staple products
and articles of diet thereafter. He was not a
physician, but the sick constantly appealed to
him for relief and he and his wife dispensed
simple remedies with common sense advice con-
cerning the care of the sick and of little children.
A good boys' school, a girls' seminary, a
102 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
strong evangelical church and community de-
veloped in a comparatively short time from very
modest beginnings. Schools and preaching
centers were established in the surrounding vil-
lages until there were twenty-eight in the
vilayet from which came girls and boys pre-
pared for entrance into the two boarding-schools
in Bitlis and from which radiated enlightenment
and helpful influence to all parts of the province.
The Havedorig region was a remarkable ex-
ample of the changes wrought by these centers.
Its inhabitants when Mr. Knapp first visited
them were bloodthirsty, thievish brigands; fif-
teen years later the church at Havedorig was
working a reform among the hundred villages
of Moush plain, and the people were gradually
becoming peaceful, law-abiding, prosperous and
intelligent.
The unusual experiences of the missionaries
both at home and while travelling and touring
the villages would fill a volume. One of Mr.
Knapp's journeys was a voyage down the Tigris
River to Mosul on a raft made of wood resting
on over a hundred inflated goat-skins. At night
the travellers would anchor the raft near some
village. Passing through the narrows between
Home lite in an Armenian village
Life in an Armenian refngee camp — Port Said
THE PAEENTS OF GEOEGE P. KNAPP 103
high rocky bluffs they were shot at by robber
Kurds.
During another journey he and his com-
panion, Dr. George C. Raynolds of Van, were
attacked and robbed by the noted brigand,
Mousa Bey.
When the Russo-Turkish war broke out Mr.
Knapp was taking his oldest son George to
Constantinople to send him thence to America.
He had to consign the boy to the care of the
captain of a Black Sea steamer and hasten back
to his other children and the three American
ladies, left alone in Bitlis. Troops from Bagdad
on their way to the front near Erzerum passed
through the city; several thousand Kurdish
Volunteers from the South plundered the
Armenians of Bitlis, outraging and killing many ;
they said they had come north not to fight but
to plunder. Many Armenians brought their
most cherished possessions to Mr. Knapp for
safe keeping. His presence restrained these
Kurds to an appreciable extent.
War was followed by terrible famine and the
missionaries opened a soup kitchen for the
destitute. Among those who came to this soup
kitchen for relief was a high-spirited, handsome
104 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
boy from the highlands of Sassun who later
worked his way through the mission school and
theological seminary, married a graduate of the
Mt. Holyoke Seminary of BitHs, was for a time
a preacher and teacher in the villages, and finally
became pastor of the church in Bitlis. This was
Khachig Vartanian, the story of whose martyr-
dom and that of his wife has been told in the
preceding chapters.
At the time this young lad first entered
Bitlis the pastor of its Protestant Church was
Rev. Simon Tavitian, who was another remark-
able product of the mountain fastnesses of
Sassun, a man of originaHty of character, ex-
traordinary learning and great practical ability —
a revered leader of his people.
Except for two years, 1902-1904, when Dr.
Herbert Underwood was stationed there, never
was there an American, and seldom a native,
physician in Bitlis, and this lack was the cause
of many hard experiences. At one time when
Mrs. Knapp was dangerously ill her husband
consulted by telegraph with Dr. Parmelee in
Erzerum and followed his directions success-
fully. After Dr. C. D. Ussher went to Van in
1899 he considered himself responsible for the
THE PAEENTS OF GEOBGE P. KNAPP 105
Bitlis station as well, and often crossed the lake
or made the hard four-days' journey over the
mountains, to minister to its missionaries in
their need. But this was after Mr. and Mrs.
Knapp's time.
Sixteen years elapsed between Mr. Knapp's
first and second furlough. In 1884 he was re-
leased for greatly needed rest by the transfer
of Rev. Royal M. Cole and his wife from
Erzerum to Bitlis, where they remained until
1907. During the Russo-Turkish war, Mr. Cole
had cared very efHciently for the wounded sol-
diers in Erzerum. This city was one of the
strategic points of the war and was taken by
the Russians in 1878.
In 1890 Mr. Knapp's own son George became
his associate in the work at Bitlis and three
years later a daughter also. His last days were
passed among the people he had laboured for;
he was spared the terrible grief of witness-
ing the massacres of 1895-96, for he died on
March 12, 1895.
The missionaries had been bitterly opposed
by the Gregorian priesthood at the first. But
now the Gregorians requested that Mr. Knapp's
grave should be within their church and begged
106 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
the privilege of taking a share in the burial
services. These vi^ere exceedingly impressive
and deeply significant of the changes brought
about in the space of one man's lifetime, largely
through the quiet influence of his own per-
sonality.
George Gushing Knapp's preeminent gift was
the gift of inspiring confidence and affection.
His people beHeved absolutely in his sincerity,
his interest in them, his desire to help them,
his devotion to the Master he served. He won
the respect and admiration of those who were
hostile to his religion, who were incapable of
understanding his motives. One of his staunch-
est friends was a Kurdish neighbour, a man of
position and influence, whose loyalty was in
war and massacre put severely to the test and
did not fail.
His was never the critical censorious spirit
that mars so many forceful personalities; his
never the tongue to wound with cruel thrust
like that of a rapier. He would live at peace
with all men. But underneath all his gentle-
ness was the granite of his native state: he
could never be moved by physical danger or the
fear of men where principle was at stake.
THE PAEENTS OF GEOEGE P. KNAPP 107
Mrs. Knapp was a very important factor in
the success of the mission at Bitlis. In her girl-
hood she had had an intense craving for knowl-
edge, and secured with much hard work an
education for herself and later for two younger
sisters. She became assistant principal of
Castleton Seminary, having charge of its girl
students and governing them with love and
sympathetic understanding.
After she had passed over to the Misses Ely
the school for girls she had estabHshed in Bitlis,
she gave much of her time to the boys* school,
always teaching a number of classes and having
full charge of the boarding department. She
mothered the boys far from their own village
homes, looking after their clothing, giving them
work with which to pay their way, and super-
vising their discipline. No boy so stubborn and
insubordinate but could be melted and subdued
by an interview with " Khanum." She had a
remarkable gift for dealing with people, for
calming their angry passions and making them
" see reason," obey the dictates of common
sense and good judgment and forget their
prejudices and animosities. Throughout her
life she was constantly called upon to settle
108 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
quarrels and adjust difficulties, and many a
delicate and complicated situation did she
handle with the skill of a born diplomat.
Besides her school work she had the teaching
of her own children and the cares of house-
keeping, A notable cook herself, she trained
successive Armenian women to something ap-
proaching her own perfection in that line, and
her hospitable home was an oasis in the desert
of miserable Oriental khans for the infrequent
European travellers through that region.
Her busy days, with their great number and
variety of regular tasks which left not a moment
unoccupied, were further filled — to overflow-
ing— by incessant interruptions: the visits of
Turkish men — wives of high officials — the visits
of families of wealth and influence, the appeals
of all sorts and conditions of men and women
for advice, comfort, or assistance. " Khanum "
meant one woman and no other to the people of
Bitlis: an American woman with a vivid, force-
ful personality radiating sunny cheer and stimu-
lating sympathy, strong, true, intensely loving,
Christlike.
A hot summer spent in an Oriental town
utterly lacking in sanitation seriously injures
THE PARENTS OF GEORGE P. KNAPP 109
the health of children of Occidental parentage.
So Mrs. Knapp moved her family every year
to a mountain three miles from the city. There
was a small Armenian village here; its tiny
fields of cabbage and turnips, millet, wheat and
clover, rose one above another on terraces like
a green flight of stairs. On two terraces above
the highest of these camped the missionaries in
tents and dug-outs, and here Mrs. Knapp planted
a garden and tended it with never-failing de-
light, reliving in memory the childhood days
spent on her father's Vermont farm.
The Elys brought their school up here for the
summer term each year — no great undertaking
since desks, chairs, tables and bedsteads did
not have to be moved also. The girls from
secluded Oriental homes revelled in the un-
wonted physical freedom and simple pleasures
of this outdoor life. Often after the studies and
household tasks of the day, they would play
" Tag " and " Fox and Geese " and many an-
other old-fashioned game on the terrace in the
light of a full moon.
A small river almost encircled the mountain
at its base ; a waterfall in a ravine opposite filled
the air with its mild musical thunder; a brook
110 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
rushed down past the camp to water the fields
of the village whose ant-hill-like houses in their
setting of green trees were just visible from
the edge of the Knapp terrace.
It was a place absolutely shut in by moun-
tains and the world shut out — " a haunt of
ancient peace." The word " home " has always
brought instantly the picture of this quiet re-
treat before the inner eye of one, at least, whose
childhood summers were spent there.
But now the picture is as instantly followed
by the stabbing reminder that Cindian also
became in 1915 the scene of hideous carnage;
that those simple villagers were then butchered;
that many of the girlish playmates of long ago
have as women endured torture, shame and
death.
The death of her husband, the massacre of
1895, the deportation of her son, events which
followed each other within a year, almost
crushed Mrs. Knapp's brave spirit. She re-
turned to America in 1896. Here she found
new service awaiting her, service in behalf of
those she loved, and to it she gave herself un-
stintedly, self-sacrificingly, year after year.
Always keenly interested in affairs, keeping
THE PABENTS OP GEOEGE P. KNAPP 111
in close touch with scores of old friends in all
parts of the world, constantly making devoted
new friends, youthful in her enthusiasms, phys-
ically active, she lived a full life to the very end.
Her grave lies under the shadow of the
mighty Rockies, the grave of her husband un-
der the shadow of the Taurus Mountains, half
the width of the world away. The work they
estabhshed has been destroyed — the people they
loved and laboured for have been nearly an-
nihilated, the son who most closely followed in
their footsteps has died a martyr's death. But
their spirit can never die out of the world; in
the new Turkey, in the new Bitlis, it will live
on. The little town, reconstructed by the sur-
viving Armenians who call it home, and by the
Americans helping them, will become the center
of a work greater than the past has ever known
that will civilize and Christianize the whole of
Kurdistan.
XIV
GREATER LOVE HATH NO MAN
GEORGE PERKINS KNAPPinaunique
sense laid down his life for his friends,
the Armenians. He died because he
loved them, literally. This is the firm convic-
tion of those who know most about the circum-
stances of his last days.
With such a parentage as his, with a child-
hood and early boyhood spent in Bitlis, his only
playmates and schoolmates — aside from brother
and sisters — Armenian lads, it was perhaps not
to be wondered at that when he came to
America at the age of fourteen, he resolved to
return to Bitlis after completing his education.
Boy though he was when that resolve was
made, he never changed his mind but held to
that single purpose throughout his school and
college life.
Working his way through Harvard he was
graduated with the class of 1887 and entered
Hartford Theological Seminary. During his
112
GEEATER LOVE HATH NO MAN 113
Junior year at college he became engaged to
Anna Jay Hunt, daughter of Addison A. and
Clara E. Thomas Hunt of Barre, Massachusetts,
who was graduated from Mt. Holyoke Seminary
in 1886 and taught in Salt Lake City under the
New West Educational Commission until their
marriage in July, 1890. A few weeks after the
wedding, Mr. and Mrs. Knapp set sail for
Turkey.
The people of Bitlis had a pleasant way of
greeting new or returning missionaries; they
would walk two or three miles out of the city to
meet the travellers: the schoolboys and school-
girls would line up on each side of the road, sing
a song written for the occasion and present
flowers, after which every one would press for-
ward for a handshake and word of greeting.
An unusually large concourse turned out to
meet " Mr. George " and his young wife.
Middle-aged or old men who had known him
as a boy, young men who had been his child-
hood playmates, were won to renewed and
deeper affection by his quick recognition of old
friends in spite of changes wrought by the inter-
vening years, and by his ready use of the lan-
guage he had not allowed himself to forget.
114 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
Such things mean more to Orientals than to
other people; his deep and continued and sin-
cere interest in individuals and in the race as a
race wronged and oppressed, his sympathy, his
appreciation of all that was admirable in
Armenian character, customs, literature and re-
ligion completed his conquest of their hearts.
Four years after his coming something hap-
pened that increased this affection almost to
hero-worship. Petty disturbances in the Sassun
highlands west of Bitlis were magnified by
Tahsin Pasha, governor of the vilayet, into a
" rebellion " which was " suppressed " by him
with fiendish cruelty. Refugees escaping to
Bitlis brought stories of fearful atrocities per-
petrated in those remote fastnesses. Afire with
indignation and horror, Mr. Knapp wrote an ac-
count of what had happened and sent it to the
London Times, Refugees escaped to Europe
also and told their story there.
A commission of investigation was sent to
Moush, the town nearest the Sassun district.
Although Mr. Knapp's name had not appeared
in connection with the Times article, the un-
looked-for publicity the affair had gained was
ascribed to him by both Turks and Armenians.
GEEATEE LOVE HATH NO MAN 115
The latter — or rather some of the hot-headed
young men among them — ^jubilant over the
coming of the commission, were rather unwise
in their demonstrations of gratitude and thus
increased the newly aroused hostiUty towards
him of the government officials.
It was beHeved in Bitlis, at least, at that time,
that Europe, pledged to secure good govern-
ment for the Armenians, would now begin to
fulfill her promises. The massacres of 1895-96
proved how vain were these hopes.
The massacre in Bitlis took place in October,
1895. Many took refuge on the mission prem-
ises and here a number of the victims were
buried. The Turks showed their animosity to-
wards Mr. Knapp by more than one attempt to
shoot him. At the very first, a Turkish mob
rushed towards his house but was checked and
finally dispersed by the intervention of the
Kurdish neighbour who had been his father's
friend and his own.
The massacres were represented by the Turk-
ish Government as " uprisings " of the Armeni-
ans and due to Armenian revolutionary agents.
After the secret arrangement between Russia
and Turkey, made when th^ fleets of the Powers
116 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
had assembled in the Bay of Salonica, and
the coercing of Turkey by a display of naval
strength before Constantinople had almost been
decided upon, it began to be " whispered " that
the missionaries were at the back of the revo-
lutionary agents and that upon them should fall
the real blame for the blood shed by the Turks
in " suppressing disorder." This was a plausible
pretext for getting rid of them in order to make
way for the priests of the Russian Church, as
the first step in Russianizing the empire. The
Sultan prepared an irade providing for their ex-
pulsion.
It was decided to begin with Mr. Knapp. He
was openly charged with inciting the Armenians
of Bitlis to revolt, and although Mr. Hampson,
the British vice-consul who had been sent to
Bitlis after the massacres, reported that these
charges were absurd, Mr. Knapp was summoned
before the criminal court. On telegraphing to
the American minister for instructions, he was
told not to obey the summons. But during a
temporary absence of the British consul he was
" invited " to leave the city and a large guard
came to his house to escort him to the coast.
Mr. Knapp went with them, believing that his
GEEATER LOVE HATH NO MAN 117
helpless people would be punished for resistance
on his part. The Vali at Aleppo detained him
five days trying to make him sign an agree-
ment not to return to Bitlis under any circum-
stances. He steadily refused to sign, on the
ground that the charges brought against him
were entirely unfounded, and he was finally al-
lowed to proceed, still treated as a prisoner, to
Alexandretta.
Fortunately, Mr. John W. Riddle was then
the United States charge d'affaires at Constan-
tinople, and took up the matter vigorously, aided
and supported by Sir Philip Currie, the British
ambassador. The Turkish Government prom-
ised to have the missionary delivered to the
American consul at Alexandretta on his arrival
there but the consul wired Mr. Riddle on April
23rd that the Alexandretta authorities had re-
fused to give up Mr. Knapp and intended to
expel him from Turkish territory by compelling
him to embark on a steamer saiHng for Europe
April 24th. Mr. Riddle made energetic repre-
sentation to the Turkish Government demand-
ing that the latter respect its engagements, and
in order to give emphasis to his remarks he tele-
graphed to the commander of the United States
118 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
cruiser, Marblehead, anchored at Mersina, to go
to Alexandretta and place the cruiser at the
disposal of the consul at that port. The Porte
no sooner became aware of this telegram than
orders were sent to Alexandretta for the release
of Mr. Knapp.
The next step should have been to insist on
Mr. Knapp*s rights as an American citizen, to
treat the charges brought against him as ab-
surd, and to demand that he be permitted to
return at once to his mission. Such action was
taken by Sir Philip Currie in the case of Rev.
F. W. MacCallum, who was also deported from
his station some months later, but who was a
British subject, a Canadian. The Porte imme-
diately complied with the ambassador's de-
mands. The cases of these two missionaries
were object lessons in the difference between
the policies of England and of the United States
with respect to the status of their citizens
abroad.* Dr. MacCallum returned immediately
to his station ; Mr. Knapp waited in Constanti-
nople for a " trial," but in vain.
* These cases, however, put an end to the plan for the
general expulsion of missionaries. The irade referred to
was never made public.
GEEATER LOVE HATH NO MAN 119
Finally he gave up the attempt to secure the
trial and came to America, his wife and children
and mother, who had left Bitlis soon after his
deportation, having preceded him hither. For
two years he worked hard to secure funds in
this country for the care of thousands of Arme-
nian orphans left desolate by the massacres.
In 1899 he returned to Turkey, going to Har-
poot to take charge of fifteen hundred of these
orphans. The mission here had suffered
severely during the massacres; most of its
buildings were in ruins. The orphans were
scattered here and there where room could be
found for them ; Mr. Knapp bought land ad-
joining the mission premises, put up a building
suitable for a home for the girls, centralized
the preparation of food as an economical
measure, and established a bakery which be-
came a source of revenue as well as a saving of
expense. The whole orphanage work was en-
larged and splendidly organized. Rev. Thomas
C. Richards, in an article published in The Con-
gregationalist for December 9, 1915, gives some
details concerning it:
" His perfect mastery of the language and
intimate knowledge of Armenian ideals and
120 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
ideas made him just the man for the place. He
secured financial help for the work in Eng-
land and Switzerland and from Armenians in
America who had great confidence in him.
" His aim was to help these orphans to help
themselves. The boys were all taught some
trade, tailoring, shoemaking, carpentering, and
the like. The girls, besides learning to do all
kinds of domestic work, were taught to weave
ginghams and make thread lace. The late
George C. Williams, president of the Chemical
National Bank of New York, believed in Mr.
Knapp and his work so much that he gave the
funds to start a plant for the making of Oriental
rugs. In the State Department at Washington
is a magnificent specimen of the work accom-
plished. It is a double-faced silk rug in the
form of an American flag, twelve feet by four,
representing two years' work if done by one
individual. On the flag is this inscription,
' Presented in gratitude to the United States
Government by the Armenian Orphans of Har-
poot, Turkey.'
" Much more might be written of the agri-
cultural training, of the silk culture, of the mills
and bakery that could turn the wheat into
GEEATER LOYE HATH NO MAN 121
bread, but enough has been shown of this one
venture and reHef measure to remind one of
Cyrus Hamlin and his resourcefulness.
" In 1908 a massacre occurred at Adana and
Minot Rogers was killed. At that time, by
grape-vine telegraphy, news of an impending
massacre came to Harpoot. Mr. Knapp's two
daughters had gone to Ichme, a village five or
six hours away, with a native Armenian pas-
tor's family to spend their spring vacation.
Convinced of the danger, George Knapp went
to the VaH of Harpoot and found the most
prominent Armenians in the city there on a
like errand. The Governor pooh-poohed the
idea of any danger; besides, he had sent four
soldiers out there for protection. Finding the
missionary determined to go that night to the
village where his daughters were, the Vali gave
him an escort of twenty soldiers and one officer.
As day broke they reached Ichme to find the
children and village safe.
*'Why didn't you do it before? You can't,
now the * Hat-wearer ' is come," said one of the
soldiers to the Moslems, not realizing how well
the missionary understood Turkish.
" The Kurds were massed in a ravine back of
1?2 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
the town. Another company were in the
mosque. They had planned just as deadly and
brutal work as actually happened at Adana, but
were forestalled. The four soldiers sent the
day before arrived much later in the day.
" Now, hardest of all, this father had to go
back in a few hours to his post at Harpoot, for
no one could foretell what would happen there.
If he took his girls back with him, a panic would
certainly follow. So he left those daughters of
his, dearer than life to him, as hostages of peace
and security. With two soldiers he went back
and was in Harpoot on duty that night. A
week later those girls came home under the
escort of the brave Armenian pastor, whose
courage had done much to stay the massacre
until Mr. Knapp arrived. Who can tell the
courage it took to leave those girls behind?
"All this was in the day's work to him. He
was as modest as he was brave. Only by re-
peated cross-examination could one extract his
story. He absolutely refused to be regarded as
a hero, but he was one of the noblest.
" His ideals of duty never took himself into
account. If he had so willed his great linguistic
ability and his business enterprise might have
GEEATER LOVE HATH NO MAN 123
won him fame and fortune in the Near East.
Nothing could tempt him from his service to
his Master and his brother, the Armenian."
Mr. Knapp's efforts at Harpoot were not con-
fined to the orphanages. He taught classes in
the college and theological seminary, he toured
the villages, he was station treasurer; indeed,
he had too many kinds of work to do — the usual
experience of missionaries in undermanned sta-
tions— and yet he was always reaching out to
grasp new opportunities, try new experiments.
A big farm on which the orphan boys in his
charge should learn efficient Western methods
of cultivating the soil was a project dear to his
heart which he was forced to abandon.
With it all he never ceased to study, to per-
fect himself in the languages of the country,
and a knowledge of the history, the customs,
the prejudices of its people. He was always
very patient with the Armenians, considerate,
making allowances for their ignorance and the
deteriorating effect of centuries of oppression
on their character. He was not always patient
or tactful with his associates, a little quick to
criticize, somewhat hasty and impulsive in action
and judgments.
124 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
But there never was a man more quick to
acknowledge a mistake or fault, more eager to
make reparation or apology; his humility was
very great and very sincere.
In 1909 he came to America on furlough in
time to be with his mother during the last
month of her life. He returned to Turkey the
following year, going to Bitlis, which greatly
needed another missionary. His wife remained
in America for the sake of their children, ex-
pecting to join him within a year, but was de-
tained by circumstances. In 1914 she had en-
gaged passage on a steamer to return to Turkey
when the outbreak of the war caused all sail-
ings to be cancelled by the Board.
During the awful events of June and July,
1915, in Bitlis, Mr. Knapp was tireless in his
efforts to relieve suffering, and to mediate with
the Turkish officials in behalf of his people.
He had been ** much respected by and accept-
able to the Turks in a business and social way "
during the whole of his missionary life, in spite
of the 1896 experience, but now all was changed.
The Turks were anxious to get rid of all in-
convenient witnesses of what they had done to
the Armenians. The story of their attempt to
GEEATER LOVE HATH NO MAN 126
deport all the Americans from Bitlis has been
told in the eleventh chapter, together with the
incident of the shot fired by the disguised
Armenian, which was the pretext seized upon
by the officials for sending off Mr. Knapp with-
out delay.
He was allowed to take with him an Armenian
boy and a Turkish servant. The latter returned
from Sert.
" We waited in vain for a telegram from
Diarbekir," wrote Miss McLaren. " The serv-
ant told us that Mr. Knapp planned to go to
Harpoot as soon as he could get a conveyance.
It was not until some time had passed that the
doctor (Mustifa Bey) came and told us that it
was reported that Mr. Knapp was ill in Diar-
bekir. This was only to prepare us for the
worst, for in a moment or two he said that it
was reported that Mr. Knapp had died of
typhus. From his manner and the way he told
the story, I judged that he felt that Mr. Knapp's
death had not been a natural one. No very
satisfactory reply to inquiries was ever received
from the government. A doctor who claimed
to have attended him gave a detailed account of
the run of the fever and the pulse evidently
126 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
made up entirely by a man who knew little or
nothing of typhus fever,"
The Armenian boy was sent from Diarbekir
to Harpoot at Consul Davis's demand but could
give no information concerning the cause of Mr.
Knapp's death. After investigation, both Dr.
Atkinson of Harpoot and the American consul
arrived at the conviction that it was not a
natural one. The truth will probably never be
known, but that he died the death of a martyr
is practically certain. Dr. Andrus, Dr. Thorn
and Miss Fenenga, later deported from Mardin,
were shown his grave by a soldier who claimed
to be one of those who had borne him to his
last resting place. It is a lonely and unmarked
grave, but a cenotaph has been placed in the
cemetery at Forest Hills, Boston, by his cousin,
Mr. George B. Knapp, whose fatherly affection
and interest followed him throughout his whole
career. His life ended in the city where the
missionary life of his parents began, but the
manner of its end has made his memory not
only especially dear and sacred to hundreds of
survivors of the martyr race he loved and
worked for but a vital influence in their lives.
These lives will be his best eulogy.
XV
MISS McLaren falls ill; GERMAN
OFFICERS VISIT BITLIS
T^
HE girls and women who were per-
■ mitted to remain in Bitlis on condition
that they assist in the hospital, began
to do washing, sewing and cooking for the sol-
diers, but in their own schoolhouse and under
Miss Shane's supervision. The pastor's wife
was very helpful in overseeing this work.
After Mr. Knapp was sent away it was re-
ported that Miss Shane must go as soon as she
was strong enough to travel. For several
weeks her trunk was packed in readiness to
leave at a moment's notice. One day the mili-
tary commandant came to see Miss McLaren
in company with Mustifa Bey; Miss Shane
happened to step into the room and the com-
mandant demanded the reason for her still be-
ing in Bitlis. Mustifa Bey said that she was
still having fever and was not able to travel.
This was true : she had overtaxed her strength
127
128 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
after her illness and her temperature had gone
up to 102 and stayed there for several days.
The explanation was accepted and the matter
allowed to drop.
During the weeks when she thought she
would have to leave, Miss Shane decided to
ask the Vali if she might take some of her girls
with her. She talked the matter over with the
women and it was known that the pastor's
daughter was one for whom she would make a
special plea. But the girl herself came to Miss
Shane's room with this request:
" Miss Shane, I hear that you are going to
ask the Governor for permission to take me with
you. If that is true, please do not, please ask
him if you can take my mother. They think
she has money and it is more dangerous for her
to stay than for me."
The mother, a woman of great beauty of
character, died August 27th of typhus.
Deegeen Heghene, Kevork Efifendi's widow,
had acted as Miss Shane's nurse during part of
her illness, at the same time taking almost the
entire responsibility for the care of the girls.
Later she became her most valuable helper in
the care of the orphans and of the household.
MISS MoLAEEN FALLS ILL 129
and often acted as her interpreter. Her quiet
demeanour won the respect of all the Turks
with whom they had to deal.
Not long after her husband's martyrdom her
baby died. This was the only occasion on which
she seemed to be unable to control her grief.
It was heart-breaking to see her chnging to the
dead child, kissing its cold face and calling its
name. It was thought best she should not at-
tend the burial service but her piteous cries
followed the little coffin as it was carried out of
her sight.
It seemed to Miss McLaren that her chief
business that summer was burying the dead or
seeing that it was done, preparing the bodies
herself, often, because people were afraid of con-
tracting typhus. After Sister Martha's death
she resumed her work in the Turkish hospitals,
of which there were ten or twelve in the neigh-
bourhood which had to be visited every day.
In September she herself fell ill with typhus,
was attended by a Syrian doctor on the hospital
staff and nursed by Miss Shane and two Arme-
nian girls.
The bankers who had fled from the city when
the Turks evacuated it on the approach of the
130 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
Russians, a few days after their return called on
the two ladies and told them that they would
never forget the horror of what they had seen
on the road. The Bitlis River, a shallow moun-
tain stream, was filled, and the banks covered,
with bodies in all stages of decomposition;
bodies were lying on both sides of the road and
sometimes the highway itself was obstructed
by heaps of the dead. In one place, for the
space of about two rods, the road was covered
with corpses over which Turks would force
their horses to go.
What had impressed them most was the sight
of children alive and alone among the dead,
wailing piteously for the help and comfort that
could not come, or sitting quietly, too young to
realize the horror of what had happened.
A few days before the bankers themselves
had left the city a company of one thousand
Armenian soldiers had been sent from Bitlis
entrusted with government books and papers.
They had been set upon and killed and their
bodies left where they had fallen. The govern-
ment archives were scattered all over the hillside.
Hundreds of the fleeing Moslem ci\ Hans died
from illness and exposure. The Vali on one
MISS McLAEEN FALLS ILL 131
occasion said to Miss McLaren : "All this suffer-
ing through sickness and war has come upon the
Moslems as a just punishment from a righteous
God, because of what we have done to the
Armenians. Some of them deserved punish-
ment but we went too far, and now God is
punishing us for it." This conviction did not
make him put an end to the atrocious treatment
of women, however.
In the latter part of September he was re-
placed by a man who was proud of the fact that
he had cleaned out the Christian population of
Erzingan — a brother-in-law of Djevdet Bey.
In October two German officers on their way
to Persia stopped at Bitlis with instructions to
learn what had become of Sister Martha, as the
German Embassy was unable to get any satis-
factory answer to its telegrams. To these men
were entrusted letters to her friends giving an
account of her experiences in Bitlis, her last
days and her dying messages, and these were
safely delivered.
None of the Americans' letters were leaving
the Bitlis post-office and their telegrams were
changed and curtailed so that they often failed
to convey the intended message. Therefore
132 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
Miss Shane asked the senior officer if he would
get a letter to the American Embassy. He re-
plied that he would send it to the German Em-
bassy asking to have it passed on to the Amer-
ican. She thereupon wrote a fairly detailed
account of the events of the few days preceding
Mr. Knapp's deportation, and this letter also
reached its destination.
These officers listened with interest to the
story of what had taken place in Bitlis. They
sent food to the women kept in prison in a
starving condition, and later they gathered up
children and brought them to the American
ladies. Because of their evident sympathy for
the Armenians they incurred the suspicion of
the government and were constantly shadowed
by spies.
XVI
MUSTIFA BEY AND THE SCHOOLGIRLS
AFTER the departure of the two young
Armenian surgeons whose fate is de-
scribed in the seventh chapter the hos-
pitals had been left without a surgeon and this
had caused a great deal of suffering. At last
another doctor had said that he would do the
best he could if Sister Martha would help him.
She really knew more than he did and he would
ask her how to make an incision and would fol-
low her directions. After that he was obliged
to perform all the operations, and unlike most
Turkish doctors he did his best and improved
noticeably. Later he was promoted to be
superintendent of the hospitals.
This was Mustifa Bey, who saved the women
and girls in the school by representing that he
needed their assistance in the hospital. He was
an Arab, had been educated in France and Ger-
many, and said to the Americans on one occa-
sion that he was ashamed of being an Ottoman
133
134 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
subject, was horrified by the massacres, and
that if ever he had the opportunity he would
give himself up to the Russians.
The responsibility he assumed was not a
light one. As he saw a great deal of the other
officials he knew that the presence of the girls
in the school was a constant thorn in the flesh
to the government. The girls were better edu-
cated than the majority of Armenian girls and
many of them were very attractive ; the military
officers stationed in the town constantly brought
pressure to bear on the authorities to deport
them in order that they might be able to take
their pick of them.
"At one time," wrote Miss Shane, " it really
seemed as if they would have to go and Mustifa
Bey seemed quite stirred up over the situation.
He told me that the government was continu-
ally finding fault with him because so many sol-
diers in the hospital were dying, but it would
not give him the material to work with nor the
necessary help. He had been feeling rebellious
for some time past, but when the Governor said
the girls must be taken away he was aroused to
the point of resistance. He told me that unless
I feared that Miss McLaren and myself might
MUSTIFA BEY AND THE SCHOOLGIRLS 135
become involved in case the government at-
tempted to take the girls, he would gather his
hospital forces and resist. He had stood all he
cared to stand from the government, had begged
to be allowed to resign his position as hospital
superintendent; had even remained in his house
two days feigning illness to avoid responsibility
under such circumstances, but he could not do
this indefinitely and he might as well meet his
fate defending his own rights.
" I told him that as far as the government
was concerned the girls had really been placed
under his protection, and that if he opposed
their being taken on the ground that he needed
their assistance I hardly saw how we could be
held responsible — the decision was his to make,
and I would be more than willing to have him
resist any attempt to take the girls when the
matter came to a final issue.
" Before he spoke to me he had written to
Djevdet Bey to countermand the order for the
taking of the girls. No answer had come and
several days of uncertainty had passed. In the
meantime the two German officers had arrived
in the city and had called. I regretted not hav-
ing appealed to them on the subject and wrote
136 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
a letter to the senior officer explaining the situa-
tion and asking him to use his influence with the
Governor. He and his aide called again, said
they were on their way to see the Vali and
thought it best that I go with them that we
might present the matter together. Miss Mc-
Laren was just recovering from typhus at the
time and could not go with us.
" We found Djevdet Bey with the Governor
and after some discussion the former gave his
assurance that the girls would be allowed to
remain as long as they were assisting in the
hospitals. The Governor also gave his consent.
Djevdet Bey later complained to Miss McLaren
because Mustifa Bey had thought it necessary
to get him mixed up in the affair by writing the
letter, but on this occasion he did not seem
averse to assuming responsibility for the de-
cision.
" We could never be certain that Djevdet Bey
would not change his mind even if he sincerely
meant what he said at this time and of this we
could not be sure. He was in the city only
occasionally and then for short periods of time
and the Vali always kept us in a state of uncer-
tainty.
MUSTIPA BEY AND THE SCHOOLGIELS 137
" Commander Khaleel Bey sent word from
Moush that he needed more doctors and Bitlis
must furnish its quota. Mustifa Bey appealed
to higher authorities in Erzerum and was told
not to send any as they were needed in BitHs.
Khaleel Bey replied that if they were not sent
his men would come and take them by force.
The hospital building opposite us was prepared
for the siege. The girls were in the school
building and all doors and gates were barred.
However, Khaleel Bey thought better of his
decision to use force and we escaped being
dangerously near a scene of battle.
" Complaint was constantly being made that
the girls were not doing enough to warrant
their staying. Mustifa Bey said that he him-
self was placed in a very embarrassing situation,
that he was being made the butt of ridicule and
censure for keeping the girls. Since he could
not guarantee their ultimate safety he could not
understand why I would not allow them to be-
come the wives of officers who wanted them. I
told him that our religion did not sanction this,
that there was not a girl in the school who was
not free to become the wife of a Turk if she
chose to do so, but that I was staying in Bitlis
138 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
>.
for the very purpose of preventing their being
forced into Turkish homes against their vi^ill.
" That he did not attempt to make the
situation easier for himself by forcing the girls
to marry Turks is to his credit. Later, how-
ever, he insisted on having seven girls as as-
sistants in the operating room. Up to this time
the girls had been working in the school build-
ing under my supervision and I disliked the idea
of their going out among the Turks. When I
objected he became very angry, said it was
necessary that their work should be more in
evidence if they were to be allowed to stay; he
needed their assistance; if I did not give my
consent he would not employ them in the hos-
pital longer, and the government could do what
it pleased with them.
" Later he seemed ashamed of his show of
anger, said I could choose those who were to
assist him, and assured me that they would be
treated with respect and that I was free to visit
the operating room often to see how they were
getting along. I chose seven of the teachers,
young women who had been brought up from
their early years under the care of the Ely sis-
ters, and said to them :
MUSTIFA BEY AND THE SCHOOLGIRLS 139
" ' The real test has now come for you. If
you cannot make the Turk realize that there is
a vital difference between your religion and his,
your principles and his; that there is something
in you which makes it impossible for you to
descend to his plane of living and thinking, and
that you do not shrink from death when the
question of principle and loyalty to your re-
ligion is at stake, your only means of protection
is gone and any breaking down of barriers
means danger for yourselves and all the others.'
" The girls never had cause for complaint.
Miss McLaren in her work in the hospital often
had occasion to visit the operating room and
she reported that they were faring well and
were getting some valuable training.
" Some of the women were sent out to the
more distant hospitals to work. They were
kindly and respectfully treated, with the excep-
tion of a few who were sent to the monastery
outside of the city which was used as a hospital
for convalescents. These women were in con-
stant danger until Mustifa Bey was prevailed
upon to replace the superintendent of this work
by a more trustworthy man."
XVII
MISS McLaren and miss shane
OBLIGED TO LEAVE BITLIS
THE two ladies could send out no letters
and but few telegrams. In November
the American ambassador at Constan-
tinople urged them to leave. Three telegrams
were sent in reply stating that they were re-
maining voluntarily and did not wish to go, but
he thought these telegrams not genuine, sent
an order for them to go to Harpoot, and had the
American consul in that city send his kavass to
Bitlis to accompany them.
Miss McLaren and Miss Shane left BitHs on
November 30th. Women and children were
still being hunted from house to house through-
out the city and a few days earlier the two
ladies had seen a number held under guard in
the open without food or shelter, huddled to-
gether in small groups. Their faces did not
seem human, so emaciated were they with hun-
ger and suffering.
140
OBLIGED TO LEAVE BITLIS 141
The road to the south had been partially
cleared up in October, just before some German
officials were expected to pass that way, going
to Mosul, but evidences of the summer's work
were still to be seen; in every gully were the
remains of human bodies.
While the ladies were in Diarbekir a new
massacre took place, and during the next two
days they saw bodies lying on or near the road,
some of them stripped of their clothing, many
terribly mutilated; the faces of three in one
group had been so mutilated that no features
were discernible and the bodies were one mass
of gashes. A dog was standing over one body ;
as the travellers drew near they could see that
he had already gnawed a part of the flesh from
the bones.
They passed the spot where the men had evi-
dently been led ofiE the road. It was far from
any village, a wild desolate hilly region, with
enormous jagged rocks covering the hillsides.
At this point some had evidently tried to escape
the torture and death that awaited them in the
ravines. They had been shot and left where
they fell; many bodies were in plain view, of
others an arm or a leg could be seen projecting
142 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
from behind some rock. Further on was the
body of an old white-haired woman lying near
the road, a deep gash in her forehead.
All along the way were seen villages com-
pletely destroyed by fire.
The travellers passed a group of at least fifty
men who were marching along under guard,
and were told that these, too, were soon to be
killed. They were all that had been left of a
very large party of Armenian soldiers who had
come from Erzerum. Two of the Erzerum
mission schoolboys had been with them but suc-
ceeded in escaping and found refuge as helpers
in the American hospital at Harpoot.
Miss McLaren assisted in this hospital after
her arrival in Harpoot, Miss Shane in the girls'
school and among the Armenian refugees from
further north.
In the summer of 1917 after the breaking of
diplomatic relations with the United States,
they left with the Harpoot missionaries for
America. Not until they reached Switzerland
did they learn the truth about what had taken
place in Van in the spring of 1915, and that
there had been no " rebellion " there.
They had known that the entire population
OBLIGED TO LEAVE BITLIS 143
of the town and province had fled into the
Caucasus when the Russian army retreated in
August, for Djevdet Bey had entered the
evacuated city and later returned to BitHs. He
told Miss McLaren that Mrs. Ussher had died
of typhus in July and he had spoken with deep
feeling of the kindness shown by the mission-
aries towards the Moslem refugees whom they
had cared for on their premises during the
Russian occupation.
" I can never forget it," said he.
XVIII
SEQUELS
AGAIN the Russians entered Turkey,
occupied Van and pushed westward,
reaching Tadvan once more about the
last of January, 1916. It took the army a month
to cross the plain, eighteen miles in width, be-
tween Tadvan and Bitlis. About midway a
terrible battle was fought and the noise of it
was heard in the city.
Mustifa Bey, faithful to his trust, had refused
to yield to the great pressure brought to bear
on him to make him give up the schoolgirls left
in his charge. A few, fearing a worse fate, had
consented to become the wives of Turkish of-
ficers, and two whom he had sent south, assur-
ing them of safety in the home of his brother in
Aleppo, were stopped at Diarbekir and obliged
to work in the military hospital there. But up
to this time he had succeeded in protecting the
rest from molestation.
144
SEQUELS 145
When the Russians drew near the city, how-
ever, the Turks slaughtered in the most brutal
manner — ^with axes instead of with bullets or
bayonets — the few women who had not as yet
been deported, and Djevdet sent word to Mustifa
Bey that he must give up his charges to be put
to death. Mustifa Bey in an effort to postpone
the evil hour made illness an excuse for not
obeying at once, saying he would attend to the
matter on the morrow. He then went to the
girls and bid them prepare for a long journey,
as they were to be sent into exile at last.
It may be supposed they had no thought of
sleep that night as they busied themselves fol-
lowing his instructions. About an hour after
midnight they were startled by the sudden noise
of battle in the city itself. The furious firing
seemed to be almost under their very windows,
as the schoolhouse stood near the edge of the
bluff overlooking the most densely built-up part
of the town. The girls believed that the regular
troops were engaged with plundering hordes of
Kurds, and when there came a thunderous
knocking at their gate at five o'clock in the
morning they thought that either a band of
these Kurds had come to ravish and kill or that
146 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
the Turkish soldiers were about to hurry them
" down the road."
" Open ! We are friends — ^Armenians."
Trembling, they obeyed, to find outside a band
of Armenian Volunteers, part of the advance
guard of the Russian army, which, by sliding
down the trackless, snow-covered hills sur-
rounding Bitlis, had taken the Turks by sur-
prise and captured the city. The Moslems who
did not succeed in escaping were put to death,
but Mustifa Bey*s life was spared through the
intercession of the girls whom he had protected.
A week later these girls were taken to Van,
where some of them remained till the second
evacuation of the province, while a few went on
almost immediately to the Caucasus.
Among the Armenian Volunteers who cap-
tured Bitlis were two young men originally
natives of Kultig, a large village not far from
the city, which, like all the other villages of the
vilayet, had sufifered from massacre and de-
portation, but some weeks later than the rest.
One of these young men, Caspar, by bribing a
Turkish friend, managed to elude the soldiers
surrounding his home, and after remaining con-
cealed in the mountains for a while, succeeded
SEQUELS 147
in escaping to the Russian army, then very near
the city. When it retreated he went with it to
Russia, to return as a volunteer in 1916.
The other young man, Levone, had emigrated
to America some years before. After the war
broke out he started for Russia with the inten-
tion of fighting in the Russian army against the
Turks. He sailed on the Lusitania and when
that ship was sunk was saved by a piece of
timber by means of which he kept himself afloat
for hours until rescued. After which he carried
out his original intention and was with the Rus-
sian army which raised the siege of Van in May,
1915. Not sent on to Bitlis at this time with
the troops that never reached their objective,
he entered his old home with a victorious army
ten months later.
These Kultig men married two of the rescued
schoolgirls who were sisters. Levone Seferian,
after a three months* stay in Van, brought his
wife, Lucia, on to New York. The other young
couple remained behind and no word has been
received from them since. If living they are
probably in the Russian Caucasus, where there
are now 330,000 Armenian refugees. In August,
1915, there were about 250,000 refugees from
148 THE TRAGEDY OP BITLIS
the evacuated Van province and about 100,000
from the Erzerum and Bitlis provinces and their
condition — homeless, starving, strangers in a
strange land — was desperate indeed.
The Russian Government gave a bread ration
for a while, but it was the American Committee
for Armenian and Syrian Relief that organized
permanent and really efficient relief in this con-
gested district. It sent there Mr. Richard Hill,
late in 1915, and soon after Dr. Samuel Wilson
from Persia; both were American missionaries.
Dr. F. W. MacCallum of the Constantinople
Mission and Mr. George F. Gracey of Ourfa
went there early in 1916 and were joined some
months later by Dr. George C. Raynolds and
Rev. and Mrs. Ernest A. Yarrow, formerly of
the Van Mission, and Rev. and Mrs. Harrison
A. Maynard, who had left Bitlis for their fur-
lough in May, 1915.
Mr. and Mrs. Maynard found in the Caucasus
the women and girls who had so strangely sur-
vived the tragedy of Bitlis. Deegeen Heghene
became matron of an orphanage. Pastor Kha-
chig's daughter and her little brother were
taken into another orphanage. The little tot
who was rescued from deportation and inevi-
Ifel^
pH" L p
l€: .iiti
W ^— ■'^'Lwjjijp
HLML-^
Shoc-niakiiisj'.
Lace-work
InDUSTKI.M. KkI.IKK of the AmKKUA.N CuMMITTEli FOR
1\.f:lief in the Near East.
SEQUELS 149
table death by a Turk but would have none of
him and was consigned to the care of an Arme-
nian woman (see p. 66) was among those who
were saved.
The Americans immediately began to organ-
ize industrial relief. Crude wool and cotton
were bought and cleansed, carded, spun, woven
and made into garments and blankets by
refugees, for refugees. Refugees made spinning-
wheels, handlooms, sandals and, later, farm im-
plements. Every dollar of relief money was
thus made to do the work of two. Every in-
dividual employed supported a family averag-
ing five or six members. The aged, infirm and
helpless were given money and needy widows
with children to support were given a small
sum monthly for each child. Children were
taught trades ; a small hospital was opened and
a daily clinic held by Dr. Kennedy, who had
been sent out by the Lord Mayor of London's
Committee for Armenian ReHef. Another Eng-
lishman who worked with the American Com-
mittee most efficiently was Mr. Thomas Dann
Heald of Bristol, while Mr. Backhouse and Mr.
Catchpool of the Lord Mayor's Committee co-
operated with it in friendly and effective fash-
160 THE TEAGEDY OF BITUS
ion. In 1917 Messrs. Compton, Elmer, Par-
tridge, James, White, Williams, Mrs. White,
Mrs. Compton and Miss Orvis were sent from
America to assist in the work which had reached
proportions beyond the strength of those who
had originally organized it. Had not their
Armenian superintendents been men trained in
the mission work of Van — educated, capable,
trustworthy men, filled with the spirit of service
and cooperation, the task of the Americans
would have been an almost impossible one.
Russia's separate peace with Germany spelled
catastrophe to the relief work. The American
consul at Tiflis, Mr. F. Willoughby-Smith, sent
the American workers away. Wrote Mr. Yar-
row later:
"The following argument put forth by the
consul, I think appealed to us all and it was on
this ground that we decided to leave. It seemed
most likely that the Germans had designs on the
Caucasus and if they sent even a small force
from Odessa there was nothing to oppose them.
Then our being with the Armenians would do
them more damage than good. We would im-
mediately be interned, our equipment con-
fiscated and probably the activity of the Com-
SEQUELS 151
mittee be entirely stopped. On the other hand,
if we should withdraw and leave the work of
the Committee in the hands of local Armenian
committees the Germans might allow them to
continue. And the consul assured us that he
could arrange for the transfer of funds through
the Swedish consul or some other neutral
agency. I think it was harder for us to come
away than it would have been to stay, but we
tried to weigh the question calmly and logically
and I still believe we decided wisely. The
situation was entirely different from the one we
faced in Van three years before.* We were
warned then of what was to happen and with
our eyes open we decided to stay and share the
fate of the people with whom we had lived and
worked for so many years, but now our position
was entirely different. We were in a land for-
eign to ourselves and to the refugees to whom
we were ministering. We had given them all
our strength and intelligence, but new condi-
tions over which we had no control made it im-
possible to help further; on the contrary, our
presence with them might be a real element of
danger to their security, and with heavy hearts
*^ee Dr. Ussher*s "An American Physician in Turkey."
152 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
but free consciences we left the work to
which we had been giving the best that was in
us."
The party left Erivan March 19th. The
chance of getting anywhere with a whole skin
seemed very uncertain; the train was searched
at every stop by the Tartars ; the stations were
almost all destroyed and villages were burning
all along the way.
Mr. James ArroU and Mr. John Elder, two
young Americans, had been doing Y. M. C. A.
work among the soldiers in the Caucasus for a
short time. They secured consent from the
district secretary to remain a while at least.
Mr. Heald remained for a few days in Erivan to
complete the transfer of the work to the Arme-
nian Committees aided by Mr. McDowell of the
Persian Branch of the Relief, then in British
service, and Mr. Gracey who had become a cap-
tain in the British army. Mr. Heald left Tiflis
on the last train allowed to pass by the Tartars,
Mr. McDowell was ordered to Alexandropol
and Captain Gracey to Tiflis. (He was after-
wards made prisoner by the Bolshevists and
not set free till late in the spring of 1919.) One
of the two Y. M. C. A. men became very ill.
SEQUELS 163
the other cared for him; on his recovery they
divided the reUef work between them.
So the industrial rehef at Erivan was never
discontinued, the orphanages and hospital never
closed, throughout all the changes that took
place in that harassed region during the next
few months, though, at one time, informed by
the Armenian Dictator, Aram Pasha, that
Erivan would be in Turkish hands before many
days, Mr. Arroll and Mr. Elder prepared to
leave. But the tide of battle at Sadar Abad
turned and Erivan was saved.
Consul Willoughby-Smith left the relief work
in Tiflis in charge of Madame Plavsky, a Rus-
sian lady, and her assistant, Mr. Booman, who
was a Lett. Mr. Montesanto, vice-consul at
Vladikavkaz, cared for the refugees fleeing from
the Caucasus into Russia, of whom over fifty
thousand passed through this opening in the
great mountain barrier between the two conti-
nents : food and medical assistance was given to
thousands, milk to the children and the sick.
When the armistice was signed Mr. Maynard
at once dropped the relief work in Persia in
which he had engaged not long after leaving
the Caucasus, and hastened back to Erivan.
164 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
Mr. Yarrow left Army Y. M. C. A. work in
Vladivostok and travelled thither via India and
Egypt. The American Committee for Arme-
nian and Syrian Relief in the meantime planned
a great work of relief and reconstruction in the
Near East — where, by the way, it is entitled the
American Committee for Relief in the Near
East, or the A. C. R. N. E. It sent out early
in January, 1919, a Relief Commission of seven,
headed by Dr. James L. Barton, to investigate
conditions and organize relief. President Main
of Grinnell College was the Relief Commissioner
for the Caucasus. He cabled to New York
early in April :
" I have been handling refugee concentra-
tion along the former boundary line between
Russian and Turkish Armenia. Alexandropol,
a large center, and Etchmiadzin, a small one,
are typical. In the one are 68,000 refugees by
actual census at our bread and soup kitchens.
In the other are 7,000. Refugees have streamed
into these places hoping to find it possible to
cross the border into their former homes in
Turkish Armenia near Kars. Concentration at
these two places and many others without food
or clothing and after a winter of exile in the
SEQUELS 156
Caucasus and beyond has produced a condition
of horror unparalleled among the atrocities of
the great war. On the streets of Alexandropol
on the day of my arrival 192 corpses were
picked up. This is far below the average per
day. One-seventh of the refugees are dying
each month. . . .
" The refugees dare not go forward. They
halt on the borderland of their home. The
Turks, the Kurds and the Tartars have taken
possession of their land and will hold it by force
of arms. A line almost Hke a battle line from
the Black Sea region, where is located the
Southwestern Republic with Kars as its capital,
to the Caspian Sea, where Baku is the capital
of the Azerbeijan Republic, together with a Hne
of Turks, Kurds and Tartars between these two
extremes, holds the refugees where they are.
The total number is more than 330,000. To
these must be added the local inhabitants also
suflFering indescribable hardships. The world
appears to be unconscious of the overwhelming
human tragedy that is being enacted in the
Caucasus. The Turk and his racial confed-
erates are carrying forward with growing ef-
ficiency the policy of extermination developed
156 THE TRAGEDY OF BITLIS
during the war by the method of starvation.
Starvation is aided by typhus, and already, as
if in anticipation of the hot season, cholera is
developing. . . ."*
Later in January forty relief workers, all men,
sailed on the Pensacola, which carried a cargo of
food, clothing, medical supplies, hospital units,
ambulances, etc., for the sufferers in the Near
East. Among the workers was Dr. Ussher of
the Van Mission, and on their arrival in Con-
stantinople he was sent with several new men
up into the Caucasus.
The Caesar y the MercuriuSy the Western Belle
and the Newport News have in quick succession
carried out supplies of food, clothing and every-
thing needed for reUef and rehabilitation. On
* Cables sent from the Caucasus June 1st and 7th state:
" First relief and food ships momentarily checking tide
starvation and death. Increased and continuous aid im-
perative. Repatriation into Turkish Armenia beginning."
" Conservative estimates British and our Committee read
amount immediately needed Caucasus $1,500,000 monthly.
Committee only relief. Situation worse daily." " History
has no record of human suffering on such a scale."
Mr. Hoover has cooperated with the Committee in
every possible way but his organization is scheduled to
go out of existence July 1, 1919. Mr. Yarrow has been
appointed Deputy Commissioner for the Caucasus with
oversight of Erzerum, Van and Bitlis when these are
opened up.
SEQUELS 157
the Leviathan sailed in February about two hun-
dred and fifty more relief workers — doctors,
nurses, expert agriculturists and mechanics,
sanitary engineers and civil engineers, with
other technically trained men and women,
teachers and orphanage workers, and smaller
groups have followed these from time to time/
Miss Shane went out on the Leviathan. Miss
McLaren also intends to return to Turkey when
she has completed the nurses' training course
she entered upon soon after her return to this
country.
This is the program of the American Com-
mittee for Armenian and Syrian Relief: first, to
save the lives of the thousands upon thousands
of the victims of Turkish cruelty who are now
starving to death; next, to repatriate the de-
ported exiles (as well as the exiles in the Cau-
casus who were not deported, but fled from
their homes) who since the armistice was signed
have been striving to return to their homes from
the desert where they have been wandering for
three years; to help them rebuild their houses,
'J. Herbert Knapp, brother of George Knapp, went
out as a civil engineer with a group of relief workers
that sailed June 24, 1919.
158 THE TEAGEDY OF BITLIS
many of which have been destroyed; to supply
peasants with seed and farm implements so that
they may gain their own living from the soil
and avert famine from the whole country; to
supply artisans with the few tools and the small
sum of money which would in a very short time
enable them to support their families; to create
industries by which the thousands of women
left without male relatives may support them-
selves; most important of all, to care for the
children, most of them orphans, so efficiently, so
wisely, that they may become a great asset in
the economic, intellectual, social and spiritual
development of the country. The reconstruc-
tion of Turkey, the " key to the Old World," is
in the hands of American philanthropy.
Here is one example of the problems the
A. C. R. N. E. has to solve: "The present
movement by which the Turks are releasing
women and children who have been sequestered
in their homes is almost startling in its sweep
across the country, putting upon us enormous
responsibilities. There is no other organization
in the country to meet this situation. While
native communities are doing everything in
their power to take in these discharged people
SEQUELS 159
and give them a home, they find it impossible
to do anywhere near what is necessary to do,
and all parties turn to us. It is pathetic to see
the way in which all classes of people look upon
this Commission as almost sent from heaven to
save this stricken land from ruin."
From the one town of Aintab 30,000 were
driven out into the desert to die, and now there
are, so far as can be ascertained, only 4,000 or
5,000 alive. Whether this proportion holds
true for the rest of Turkey we cannot tell.
Undoubtedly more of the former inhabitants of
Van are still living than of any other Armenian
city. And of Bitlis, alas! the fewest. In the
fall of 1915 the government of that city had
issued a proclamation that all men who were in
hiding could come out, would be forgiven ( ! )
and set to work. Some did come out of their
holes looking like skeletons risen from the
grave. What their ultimate fate was Miss Mc-
Laren and Miss Shane do not know and aside
from these they know of but one or two who
escaped massacre.
Although few survivors may return to Bitlis,
it is of the utmost importance that the town
should be fully rehabilitated. It has been said
160 THE TEAGEDY OP BITLIS
that it IS the " door between highlands and low-
lands," the avenue of communication between
the northern and northeastern plateaus and the
Mesopotamian plains, between Persia and the
coast of the Mediterranean. The strategical
value of its position is therefore immense from
the economic point of view; from the spiritual
point of view no less great, for from this center
the Kurds of Eastern Turkey can be most
readily reached, civilized, Christianized, and for
the sake of the future of Turkey this must be
done.
The tragedy of BitHs was one of the crudest
of the war. May the future of the little town
be a future of such peace, prosperity, far-reach-
ing, civilizing influence and steady growth in
righteousness as to compensate in some meas-
ure for the hideous suffering of the past.
Printed in the United States of America
Deacidified using the Bookkeeper p
Neutralizing agent: Magnesium Oxi(
Treatment Date: J|J/^ ;
PreservationTechnoli
A WORLD LEADER IN. PAPER PRESEH
111 Thomson Park Drive
Cranberry Township, PA 16(
(724) 779-2111